Fulde-Ferrell-Larkin-Ovchinnikov vortex lattice states in fermionic cold-atom systems
Y.-P. Shim,
1
R. A. Duine,
1,2
and A. H. MacDonald
1
1
Department of Physics, University of Texas at Austin, Austin, Texas 78712, USA
2
Institute for Theoretical Physics, Utrecht University, Leuvenlaan 4, 3584 CE Utrecht, The Netherlands
Received 11 August 2006; published 2 November 2006
Condensation of atom pairs with finite total momentum is expected in a portion of the phase diagram of a
two-component fermionic cold-atom system. This unusual condensate can be identified by detecting the exotic
higher-Landau-level HLL vortex lattice states it can form when rotated. With this motivation, we have solved
the linearized gap equations of a polarized cold-atom system in a Landau-level basis to predict experimental
circumstances under which HLL vortex lattice states occur.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevA.74.053602 PACS numbers: 03.75.Ss, 71.10.Ca, 32.80.Pj
I. INTRODUCTION
Polarized two-component fermion systems tend toward
finite-pair-momentum condensates because of the Fermi ra-
dius mismatch between majority and minority components.
In superconductors, electron spin polarization can be induced
by the application of an external field or by proximity cou-
pling to a ferromagnet. Finite-momentum Cooper pair con-
densates in spin-polarized superconductors, Fulde-Ferrell-
Larkin-Ovchinnikov FFLO states, were first proposed in
the early 1960s 1,2. One important consequence of finite-
momentum pairing in an isolated superconductor is a spa-
tially inhomogeneous order parameter. There have been
many efforts in various solid-state systems to detect this ex-
otic state, including recent ones 3,4, but its definitive iden-
tification has remained elusive. The disorder that is inevita-
bly present in a solid-state system may have played a role in
the absence of a conclusive FFLO-state identification in
studies of spin-polarized superconductors.
Experimental progress 5–8 with fermionic cold-atom
systems has given rise to a strategy for realizing the FFLO
state or the related Sarma state 9 and has stimulated a great
deal of theoretical activity 10–24. The tunability of the in-
teraction between atoms via a Feshbach resonance 25,26
has made it possible to increase the strength of fermion pair-
ing and has even made the BEC-BCS crossover 27–29 ex-
perimentally accessible. On the Bose-Einstein condensate
BEC side of a Feshbach resonance fermionic atoms form
bosonic molecules which condense at low temperatures. On
the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer BCS side, the effective at-
tractive interaction between fermion atoms leads to BCS-
type pairing. In between lies the so-called unitarity limit 30
in which no weakly interacting particle description applies.
Easy control over the population of two hyperfine states
in a trapped-atom cloud makes cold-atom systems a promis-
ing candidate for FFLO-state realization. The FFLO state
competes 10–24 with a number of other states, including in
cold-atom systems states with phase-separated regions that
are respectively unpolarized and unpaired. The FFLO state is
expected to occur on the BCS side of the BEC-BCS cross-
over, at temperatures and pressures close to the normal-
superfluid phase boundary. Population imbalance in cold at-
oms plays essentially the same role as a Zeeman or exchange
field in a superconductors since pairing is dependent on en-
ergy measured from the Fermi energy for each species of
fermion. In both cases the Fermi radius of the majority spe-
cies exceeds the Fermi radius of the minority species and
pairs at the Fermi energy necessarily have nonzero total mo-
mentum.
One of the most obvious signatures of superfluidity in
fermionic cold-atom systems is the appearance of vortices
and vortex lattices when the system is rotated 31. Indeed
recent experiments 5 have observed vortex lattice struc-
tures in fermionic cold-atom systems close to the BEC-BCS
crossover region. For this reason an obvious potential signa-
ture of an FFLO state is the appearance of the exotic vortex
lattice structures they are expected to form 32–34. FFLO
vortex lattices can be wildly different from the usual hexago-
nal Abrikosov vortex lattice. The structure of the vortex lat-
tice is determined mainly 32–34 by the Landau-level index
of its condensed fermion pairs; the Abrikosov lattice forms
when the Landau level index j =0, which is the closest ap-
proximation to zero-total-momentum pairing allowed in a
system that has come to equilibrium in a rotating frame.
FFLO states in the absence of rotation can imply j 0 fer-
mion pair condensation in rotated systems. Vortices have
been observed in systems with population imbalance 6, but
so far no unusual vortex structures have been observed. This
could be due to the fact that these experiments realize the
gapless Sarma phase 24, and another reason could be that
the FFLO state is predicted by weak-coupling theory while
all experiments are in the unitary limit.
With this motivation, we report on a study of the polar-
ization and interaction strength regime over which nonzero j
pairing is expected in a rotating two-component fermion sys-
tem. We consider only the BCS side of the Feshbach reso-
nance on which FFLO physics occurs. We consider three-
dimensional systems for the sake of definiteness, although
two-dimensional systems could also be interesting experi-
mentally. Working in the corotating reference frame, rotation
is equivalent to an external magnetic field and a reduction in
radial confinement strength. All our explicit calculations are
for a uniform three-dimensional system and do not account
for confinement. In typical experiments the atomic Landau-
level splitting, equal to 2 where is the rotation fre-
quency, is much smaller than the Fermi energy. In this limit
the Landau-level index of the condensate could be deter-
mined by finding the optimal pairing wave vector on the
BCS superfluid-normal phase boundary in the absence of
PHYSICAL REVIEW A 74, 053602 2006
1050-2947/2006/745/05360210 ©2006 The American Physical Society 053602-1