©
2010 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim Adv. Mater. 2010, 22, 3052–3057 3052
www.advmat.de
www.MaterialsViews.com
COMMUNICATION
By Khalil Amine,* Ilias Belharouak, Zonghai Chen, Taison Tran, Hiroyuki Yumoto,
Naoki Ota, Seung-Taek Myung, and Yang-Kook Sun*
Nanostructured Anode Material for High-Power Battery
System in Electric Vehicles
In recent years, gasoline prices have risen in real terms to levels
not seen since the early 1980s.
[1]
As a result, demand has increased
significantly for a high-performance battery to power hybrid elec-
tric vehicles (HEVs), plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEVs), and
all-electric vehicles (EVs). At present, the total worldwide sales of
HEVs based on the nickel/metal hydride battery system are only
about 2–3 percent of all vehicle sales, even though this technology
has been on the market since 1997, because of its high cost and
poor performance. A necessary step for significant market pen-
etration of battery-powered vehicles is the development of a cost-
effective, long-lasting, abuse-tolerant battery system.
Lithium-ion batteries, which exhibit the highest power and
energy density of any existing battery systems, offer many
advantages for applications in transportation.
[2,3]
Among the
existing cathode chemistries used in lithium batteries, lithium
manganese oxide spinel (LMO) offers outstanding power capa-
bility, excellent safety characteristics, and low cost compared to
Ni- and Co-based layered oxide materials.
[4,5]
However, when
combined with the conventional carbon anode in a full cell
configuration, the resulting cell shows poor cycle and calendar
life, especially at elevated temperatures, due to the breakdown
of the solid electrolyte interface (SEI) caused by Mn dissolution
from the cathode.
[4,6–8]
In addition, carbon materials intercalate
lithium at approximately 100 mV vs. Li/Li
+
; and under high-
power charge pulses, the carbon electrode can be polarized to
such an extent that highly reactive lithium metal plates onto the
surface of the negative electrode,
[9]
potentially causing thermal
runaway because of internal shorts triggered by the formation
of lithium dendrites.
[10]
To find an anode-cathode combination that will meet the
demanding transportation requirements, we have investigated
Li
4
Ti
5
O
12
(LTO) as the anode. Unlike the conventional carbon
anode, which expands up to 16 vol% during charging, the LTO
material can accommodate up to three lithium ions in the spinel
structure with no volume change
[11–15]
( Figure 1a). As a result,
the integrity of the LTO electrode remains intact during extended
cycling. Furthermore, the high operating voltage of LTO does
not allow the growth of lithium dendrites; consequently, better
safety is expected. Despite these advantages, cells with this
anode material synthesized as micron-sized particles have failed
to meet the transportation power requirement because of LTO’s
poor electronic conductivity.
[16–19]
In an attempt to overcome this
significant drawback, others have synthesized isolated nano-size
LTO particles, which have shown improved rate capability in cell
tests.
[20,21]
However, these nano-materials have very high surface
area (over 200 m
2
/g) and low packing density, resulting in low
volumetric energy density that falls short of meeting the energy
requirement for transportation applications.
Our approach to enable this anode material was to synthe-
size a new LTO structure: micron-size ( ∼0.5–2 μm) secondary
particles (Figure 1b, left) composed of nanometer-size ( <10 nm)
primary particles (Figure 1b, right) which is similiar to our pre-
viously reported nanoporous micro-LiFePO
4
materials;
[22]
this
material is referred to as MSNP-LTO (MSNP stands for “micron
secondary nano primary”). Unlike the conventional LTO with
micron-size particles ( ∼5–10 μm), which exhibits low initial
capacity and poor rate capability (Figure 1c), MSNP-LTO has a
nano-porous structure that allows the electrolyte to penetrate
inside the particles, resulting in high accessibility of the active
material. In addition, the nano-primary particles of MSNP-LTO
allow for fast lithium diffusion because of the short lithium
pathway within the nanoparticle. As a result outstanding rate
capability can be achieved with this material when tested in a
half cell (Figure 1d) and in full cell (Figure 1Sa&b). In addition,
the nanophase structure can allow for full lithium accessibility,
resulting, thus, in high practical capacity (Figure 1d).
To assess the potential of the MSNP-LTO anode for the
HEV application, we conducted extensive testing using coin
cells with LMO cathodes. For comparison, we also tested LTO
(micron size)/LMO and carbon/LMO cells. Further details
appear in the Methods section. Figure 2a compares the area
specific impedance (ASI) for the MSNP-LTO/LMO, LTO/LMO,
and carbon/LMO cells. Hybrid electric vehicles require very
high charge and discharge pulse power for vehicle acceleration
and regenerative braking. To meet the 25-kW pulse power
requirement in HEVs, the ASI of electrodes in the cell must
be less than 35 ohm cm.
2[23]
The pulse power capability at each DOI: 10.1002/adma.201000441
[∗] Dr. K. Amine, I. Belharouak, Z. Chen
Electrochemical Technology Program
Chemical Sciences and Engineering Division
Argonne National Laboratory
9700 South Cass Avenue, Argonne, Illinois 60439 (USA)
E-mail: amine@anl.gov
Dr. T. Tran, H. Yumoto, N. Ota
Enerdel Lithium Power Systems
8740 Hague Road, Indianapolis, IN 46256 (USA)
Prof. S.-T. Myung
Department of Chemical Engineering
Iwate University
4-3-5 Ueda, Morioka, Iwate 020-8551 (Japan)
Prof. Y.-K. Sun
Department of WCU Energy Engineering and Chemical Engineering
Hanyang University
Seoul 133-791 (Republic of Korea)
E-mail: yksun@hanyang.ac.kr