LETTERS
Increased terrestrial methane cycling at the
Palaeocene–Eocene thermal maximum
Richard D. Pancost
1
, David S. Steart
2
, Luke Handley
1
, Margaret E. Collinson
2
, Jerry J. Hooker
3
, Andrew C. Scott
2
,
Nathalie V. Grassineau
2
& Ian J. Glasspool
4
The Palaeocene–Eocene thermal maximum (PETM), a period of
intense, global warming about 55 million years ago
1
, has been
attributed to a rapid rise in greenhouse gas levels, with dissoci-
ation of methane hydrates being the most commonly invoked
explanation
2
. It has been suggested previously that high-latitude
methane emissions from terrestrial environments could have
enhanced the warming effect
3,4
, but direct evidence for an
increased methane flux from wetlands is lacking. The Cobham
Lignite, a recently characterized expanded lacustrine/mire deposit
in England, spans the onset of the PETM
5
and therefore provides
an opportunity to examine the biogeochemical response of wet-
land-type ecosystems at that time. Here we report the occurrence
of hopanoids, biomarkers derived from bacteria, in the mire sedi-
ments from Cobham. We measure a decrease in the carbon isotope
values of the hopanoids at the onset of the PETM interval, which
suggests an increase in the methanotroph population. We propose
that this reflects an increase in methane production potentially
driven by changes to a warmer
1,6
and wetter climate
7,8
. Our data
suggest that the release of methane from the terrestrial biosphere
increased and possibly acted as a positive feedback mechanism to
global warming.
Although the PETM is not a direct analogue for future global
warming because it occurs during a time when global temperatures
were significantly higher than now
9
, it still allows the investigation of
rapid warming comparable to that occurring today. A significant
challenge in the investigation of terrestrial methane cycling at the
PETM is the lack of appropriate sedimentary sequences. However,
we have recently reported the identification of the PETM interval in
lake and mire sediments from Cobham, southeast England
5
. The
section, represented primarily by lignite through the PETM interval,
provides a unique opportunity to study wetland microbial processes
in a stratigraphically expanded and relatively complete continental
section. The PETM is stratigraphically constrained (Methods) and
characterized by a negative carbon isotope excursion (CIE) recorded
by plant organic matter
5
(Fig. 1). The pronounced CIE is one of the
defining characteristics of the PETM
6,9
and is typically attributed to
the catastrophic release of
13
C-depleted methane from marine gas
hydrates.
Critically, at Cobham, the 2-m sequence between the top of the
Upnor Formation and the base of the WSB (Woolwich Shell Beds) is
entirely freshwater. The black slickensided clay at the base of the sand
and mud unit contains leech cocoons, termite coprolites, pollen and
spores, but lacks dinoflagellates. The overlying sand (sand and mud
unit) contains continental and freshwater pollen and spores and lacks
the Ophiomorpha burrows indicative of saline conditions that are
present in the underlying Upnor Formation. The Cobham Lignite
Bed (lignites and included thin clay bands) contains an abundance of
continental and freshwater aquatic pollen and spores and algal cysts,
and lacks dinoflagellates
5,10
; it is in this bed, with organic carbon
contents ranging from 15 to 36 wt%, that the negative CIE has been
recorded
5
(Fig. 1). A similar sequence with a freshwater lignite
(although a thinner one than at Cobham) followed by brackish shelly
clays, has been described from the north French coast at Varengeville;
like Cobham, the CIE is recorded in the lignitic beds
11
, testifying to
the extensive nature of the low-lying area of the southwest North Sea
Basin at the time. Further to the east, in north Belgium, the Doel and
Kallo boreholes, which are down dip from Kent in the North Sea
Basin, show that the CIE occurs in a mixed freshwater and brackish
sequence
12
. Thus, the nearest occurrence of contemporaneous saline
conditions is perhaps hundreds of kilometres from the Cobham
Lignite studied here. Such a setting provides an ideal, perhaps even
unique, opportunity to examine the biogeochemical response of a
continental lacustrine/mire system to increased global temperature at
the PETM.
Examination of microbially mediated biogeochemical processes in
ancient sediments can be challenging, but biomarkers (organic com-
pounds that can be structurally related to biological precursors) have
proved to be useful in studying the ancient microbiology of, for
example, the Permo-Triassic boundary
13
. In the Cobham Lignite,
the hydrocarbon distribution is dominated by n-alkanes with an
odd-over-even carbon number predominance indicative of a
higher-plant origin
14
and exceptional abundances of hopanes and
hopenes (Fig. 2) derived from bacteria
15
. Triterpenes and sterenes
of inferred higher-plant origin are also present but in subordinate
abundances. In the polar fractions, which are discussed here only
briefly, n-alkanols and sterols, also of inferred higher-plant origin,
are predominant.
The hopanes are dominated by the C
29
,C
30
and C
31
homologues
(21-norhopane, hopane and homohopane, respectively), with the
17a,21b(H), 17b,21b(H) and 17b,21a(H) isomers all present. The
presence of abundant hopanes with the biological bb configuration
and the lack of hopanes with 22S stereochemistry, combined with high
abundances of hopenes, indicate that the Cobham Lignite is relatively
immature with regard to petroleum generation, which is consistent
with vitrinite reflectance values (R
o
5 0.39 6 0.1 (mean 6 s.d.))
10
.
Traditionally, hopanes and their precursor hopanoids have been
attributed to aerobic bacteria, but recent work has revealed an anae-
robic origin for hopanoids as well
16
; consequently, the interpretation of
hopanoid distributions and depth profiles is complex. In the Cobham
Lignite, further complexity is imposed by marked variations in hopa-
noid distributions and stereochemistry, the latter possibly being due to
changing environmental conditions during sediment deposition
17
.
1
Organic Geochemistry Unit, Bristol Biogeochemistry Research Centre, School of Chemistry, University of Bristol, Cantock’s Close, Bristol BS8 1TS, UK.
2
Department of Geology, Royal
Holloway University of London, Egham, Surrey TW20 0EX, UK.
3
Palaeontology Department, Natural History Museum, Cromwell Road, London SW7 5BD, UK.
4
Department of
Geology, The Field Museum, 1400 S. Lake Shore Drive, Chicago, Illinois 60605, USA.
Vol 449 | 20 September 2007 | doi:10.1038/nature06012
332
Nature ©2007 Publishing Group