GR Letter
Tomographic study of Paleoproterozoic carbonates as key to understanding
the formation of molar-tooth structure
Darrel G.F. Long
Department of Earth Sciences, Laurentian University, Sudbury, Ontario, Canada P3E 2C6
Received 21 September 2006; received in revised form 16 January 2007; accepted 14 February 2007
Available online 28 February 2007
Abstract
X-ray computed tomographic studies of relatively pure Paleoproterozoic limestones from the George Formation, Muskwa Assemblage, northern
British Columbia, Canada indicate that molar-tooth structures developed along linked fractures in gel-like semi-plastic carbonate mud, with a high
organic content. Where pore fluid and/or gas pressures matched confining loads, MT blobs developed. Where pressure exceeded loads, cracks
propagated into adjacent semi-elastic sediment and were rapidly filled by clusters of uniform, equant, microcrystalline carbonate. Where abundant
carbonate was not precipitated, incipient cracks and sheets collapsed leaving residual trains of microcrystalline carbonate with similar density to the
molar-tooth carbonate. Tomographic studies show that the density of calcite domains within petrographically uniform sheets of MT void-filling
calcite is uneven, suggesting that precipitation was not instantaneous, but was propagated from discrete centres.
It is here suggested that carbonate production and sediment rheology were both strongly influenced by organic matter. During early sea-floor
diagenesis microcrystalline carbonate precipitated within organic-rich sediment with high water content, possibly within decomposing mats of
microbial extracellular polymeric substances (EPS). When pore pressures in the host sediment increased in response to cyclic loading by long-
period waves, pore fluids containing EPS were injected into newly created fractures, allowing rapid precipitation of molar-tooth carbonate. Because
tomographic studies allow detailed resolution of minor density differences, they provide a useful method of evaluating structures in relatively
uniform carbonate rocks of any age.
© 2007 International Association for Gondwana Research. Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Paleoproterozoic; Carbonates; Tomography; Diagenesis; Cyclic loading by storms
1. Introduction
Molar-tooth structures are early diagenetic features of enig-
matic origin that appear to be largely restricted to fine-grained
Proterozoic carbonates deposited in mid- to upper-ramp set-
tings. The term was first used in the geological literature by
Bauerman (1885) to describe structures “resembling the
markings on the molar-tooth of an elephant” in carbonates of
the Belt Supergroup, near the Canada–USA border. This group
of structures includes predominantly downward-tapered, ver-
tical to inclined, micro-crystalline carbonate-filled crack-like
structures, which in many examples appear to be ptygmatically
folded and/or fractured due to early compaction (Fig. 1). Sub-
horizontal sheets and spherical forms (blobs) are less common.
All show signs of compaction, in both cross-section and plan
view. Some resemble extensional vein arrays and parts of
ductile shear zones that have been modified by compaction and
thinning (c.f. Maltmam, 1994; Brothers et al., 1996; Grimm and
Orange, 1997).
The fill of molar-tooth structures is characterized by pure,
uniform, equant, polygonal, blocky calcite spar 5–15 μm in
diameter (Fig. 2). These crystals lack typical cement features and
in some cases show evidence of injected sediment fill (Pratt,
1998) or internal fluid flow (Bishop et al., 2006; Bishop and
Sumner, 2006). Associated host carbonates are typically charac-
terized by wavy to crenulate lamination, suggestive of microbial
mat development.
The development of molar-tooth structures seems to be
largely restricted to the interval between 1900 and 550 Ma (Pratt,
1998; James et al., 1998; Shields, 2002), with two examples (in
siliciclastic mudstone) from the Archean (Bishop et al., 2006;
Bishop and Sumner, 2006). The major decline in abundance
Available online at www.sciencedirect.com
Gondwana Research 12 (2007) 566 – 570
www.elsevier.com/locate/gr
E-mail address: dlong@laurentian.ca.
1342-937X/$ - see front matter © 2007 International Association for Gondwana Research. Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.gr.2007.02.004