Diagnosis and Treatment of Acute Humoral Rejection After Kidney
Transplantation: Preliminary Experience
M. Crespo, M. Lozano, M. Sole, J. Mila, N. Esforzado, J. Martorell, and F. Oppenheimer
ABSTRACT
Background. Acute humoral rejection, or rejection associated with de novo production
of anti-HLA donor-specific antibodies (DSA) after kidney transplantation (KTx), is a
clinicopathologic entity that is not completely understood. Recent studies have proposed
criteria for its diagnosis, including: (1) steroid-resistant acute dysfunction; (2) positive
post-Tx donor-specific crossmatch (XM); and (3) widespread C4d deposits in peritubular
capillaries (PTC) upon renal biopsy.
Methods. During 2002, prospective screening for AHR was established at our unit,
seeking DSA post-KTx in selected cases of steroid-resistant acute rejection or acute
dysfunction in high-risk sensitized or re-Tx patients. Frozen donor lymphocytes were used
for post-Tx flow cytometry (FC) XM and high-definition flow PRA for patients with no
frozen donor cells. We treated patients diagnosed with DSA using plasma exchange and
polyclonal immunoglobulin.
Results. Post-Tx DSA studies were performed in 9 of 94 patients transplanted during
2002. We detected DSA post-Tx in 3 of 9 recipients: 2 by FCXM and 1 using
high-definition flow PRA. Two were highly sensitized pre-Tx, but the third patient was a
70-year-old woman receiving a first Tx (PRA = 0%). All 3 recipients presented with severe
steroid-resistant acute renal dysfunction during the first 2 weeks post-Tx. Biopsies showed
some features of AHR (neutrophils in PTC); 1 case showed no signs of concomitant
cellular rejection. All rejection episodes were treated successfully (XM became negative
and renal function recovered) by combining plasma exchange and polyclonal immuno-
globulin.
Conclusions. The use of specific tools, like the crossmatch, in cases of acute, steroid-
resistant renal graft dysfunction is important to identify and treat otherwise undetected
humoral mechanisms of rejection.
H
UMORAL mechanisms of rejection were identified in
the first human trials in kidney transplantation
(KTx). In the 1960s the Tx community accepted that KTx
should be performed only when the donor–recipient cross-
match (XM) was negative.
1
The relevance of de novo
humoral responses after KTx has gained much attention
during the last few years.
2
Some groups have proposed
diagnostic criteria for acute humoral rejection (AHR),
including: steroid-resistant acute dysfunction, often resis-
tant to antilymphocyte therapy; a positive donor-specific
XM post-Tx; and the presence of C4d deposits in peritu-
bular capillaries in the renal biopsy.
3,4
We used some of
these criteria to identify AHR in our KTx population and to
investigate specific treatment.
PATIENTS AND METHODS
During 2002, prospective screening for AHR was established at our
unit. Immunologic high-risk patients with suspected acute rejection
(AR) or non– high-risk patients with steroid-resistant AR were
included in the present study. Frozen donor lymph-node lympho-
cytes were stored at the time of Tx. Donor-specific XM after Tx
From the Unidad de Trasplante Renal (M.C., N.E., F.O.),
Unidad de Afe ´ resis (M.L.), and Departamento de Anatomia
Patologica (M.S.), and Instituto Clinico de Infecciones e Inmu-
nologia (ICII), (J.M., J.M.), Hospital Clinic, Barcelona, Spain.
Address reprint requests to Marta Crespo Barrio, MD, Unidad
de Trasplante Renal, Hospital Clinic, c/Villaroel 179, 08036
Barcelona, Spain. E-mail: crespo@clinic.ub.es
© 2003 by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. 0041-1345/03/$–see front matter
360 Park Avenue South, New York, NY 10010-1710 doi:10.1016/S0041-1345(03)00620-1
Transplantation Proceedings, 35, 1677–1678 (2003) 1677