TECHNICAL COMMUNICATION
The Kepler Intubation System
Thomas M. Hemmerling, MSc, MD, DEAA, Mohamad Wehbe, MASc, Cedrick Zaouter, MD,
Riccardo Taddei, MD, and Joshua Morse
Our goal in this study was to develop a robotic intubation system and to conduct a
feasibility pilot study on the use of a robotic intubation system for endotracheal
intubations. The Kepler Intubation System was developed, consisting of a remote control
center (joystick and intubation cockpit) linked to a standard videolaryngoscope via a robotic
arm. Ninety intubations were performed by the Kepler Intubation System on an airway trainer
mannequin by a single operator. The first group of 30 intubations was performed with the
operator in direct view of the mannequin (direct view group). The second group of 30
intubations was performed with the operator unable to see the mannequin (indirect view
group). Thirty semiautomated intubations were also performed during which the robotic
system replayed a trace of a previously recorded intubation maneuver (semiautomated
group). First-attempt success rates and intubation times for each trial were recorded. Trends
were analyzed using linear regression. Data are presented as mean (SD). All intubations were
successful at first attempt. The mean intubation times were 46 (18) seconds, 51 (19) seconds,
and 41 (1) seconds for the direct view, indirect view, and semiautomated group, respectively.
Both the direct and indirect view groups had a negative slope, denoting that each successive
trial required less time. The semiautomated group had a slope of 0 and a low SD of 1 second,
illustrating the high reproducibility of automated intubations. We concluded that a robotic
intubation system has been developed that can allow remote intubations within 40 to 60
seconds. (Anesth Analg 2012;X:•••–•••)
E
ndotracheal intubation is a complex procedure of
inserting an endotracheal tube (ETT) into the trachea
of an anesthetized patient to allow artificial ventila-
tion. Endotracheal intubations, commonly performed with
high success rates in anesthesia departments, can be asso-
ciated with lower success rates in emergency departments,
where intubation success rates can be as low as 70% at first
attempt and 89% at second attempt.
1
The prehospital
success rates of endotracheal intubations have been re-
ported to be as low as 49.1%,
2
performed by rural basic
emergency medical technicians.
A study conducted by Tighe et al. demonstrated the
possibility of using a multipurpose surgical robot to assist
in airway management
3
; however, the expense of such a
system prohibits its widespread adoption for this applica-
tion. In addition, urologists used the da Vinci surgical
system for either oro- or nasopharyngeal fiberoptic intuba-
tion, which is not the standard practice in anesthesia.
However, recently widespread use of videolaryngoscopic
devices has increased, and they have been introduced into
guidelines of difficult airway, with some anesthesiologists
advocating their standard use in everyday practice.
4
This article presents the development and feasibility
pilot study of the Kepler Intubation System (KIS), a
robotic system developed using low-cost, commercially
available components for performing endotracheal intuba-
tions. This system is named in honor of the German
mathematician and astronomer Johannes Kepler, best
known for his laws of planetary motion.
METHODS
A remote-controlled robotic system was developed to in-
tubate using a standard videolaryngoscope. This system is
composed of 4 main components: a ThrustMaster T.Flight
Hotas X joystick (Guillemot Inc., New York, NY), a JACO
robotic arm (Kinova Rehab, Montreal, Quebec, Canada), a
Pentax AWS videolaryngoscope (Ambu A/S, Ballerup,
Denmark), and a software control system. Both the Pentax
AWS videolaryngoscope and the JACO robotic arm are
medical devices currently available on the market. The
software control system was developed in C sharp (Mi-
crosoft Corporation, Redmond, WA), and the graphical
user interface was developed in LabVIEW (National Instru-
ments, Austin, TX). The setup also included a commercial
Webcam (Microsoft Corporation, Redmond, WA) placed
laterally to the mannequin, providing a video feed of the
videolaryngoscope going into the mannequin’s mouth (Fig.
1, right panel).
The software control system of the KIS comprises a
client and a server to allow intubations to be performed
remotely from the operating room. The client and server
communicate with each other via the Internet. The main
interface of this system is the KIS Intubation Cockpit
(shown in Fig. 1).
Ninety endotracheal intubations were performed using
an airway trainer mannequin (Laerdal Airway Manage-
ment Trainer, Laerdal Medical, Stavanger, Norway) by the
same anesthesiologist (T.H.) via a robotically mounted
standard videolaryngoscope to determine first- attempt
success rate and the average intubation time. The intuba-
tion time was defined as the start of moving the KIS from
From the Department of Anaesthesiology, McGill University, Montreal,
Quebec, Canada.
Accepted for publication November 4, 2011.
Funding: Departmental funding.
Conflict of Interest: See Disclosures at the end of the article.
Reprints will not be available from the authors.
Address correspondence to Professor Thomas M. Hemmerling, MD, DEAA,
Department of Anaesthesiology, McGill University, Montreal General Hos-
pital, 1650 Cedar Avenue Montreal, H3G 1A4, Quebec, Canada. Address
e-mail to thomas.hemmerling@mcgill.ca.
Copyright © 2012 International Anesthesia Research Society
DOI: 10.1213/ANE.0b013e3182410cbf
XXX 2012 • Volume X • Number X www.anesthesia-analgesia.org 1