Vol. 11: e??-e??, December 2006
CASE
REPORT
e1
Key words:
Anorexia, cognitive rigidity,
remediation, set shifting,
flexibility training,
ecological validity.
Correspondence to:
Dr. Kate Tchanturia, PhD,
PO 59, EDU, Institute of
Psychiatry,
16 De Crespigny Park,
London SE5 8AF, U.K.
E-mail: spjeket@iop.kcl.ac.uk
Received: January 30, 2006
Accepted: March 10, 2006
Can cognitive exercises help treat
anorexia nervosa?
K. Tchanturia, J. Whitney, and J. Treasure
King’s College University of London, Institute of Psychiatry, Eating Disorders, London, United Kingdom
ABSTRACT. Cognitive remediation therapy (CRT) is used as an intervention for people with
brain lesions and psychosis. This case report demonstrates the possible benefits of introduc-
ing CRT into treatment packages for anorexia nervosa (AN). In our previous work, we report-
ed that people with AN demonstrate inflexibility in cognitive set-shifting tasks. Weight gain
alone does not improve the neuropsychological profile in set-shifting tasks. This case report
illustrates how training programmes can address problems in cognitive rigidity. We
acknowledge the limitations of case studies, however, this is a starting point in exploring the
possibilities of introducing CRT as part of the treatment of AN.
(Eating Weight Disord. 11: e?-e?, 2006).
©
2006, Editrice Kurtis
INTRODUCTION
Anorexia nervosa (AN) is a complex, mul-
tifactorial disease with high levels of dis-
ability and mortality with high costs to the
individual and society.
Although the disease is characterized by
pathological weight loss, simply gaining
weight does not improve the psychopathol-
ogy features related to thinking style. More
research evidence is needed to clarify mod-
els of information processing in AN, in
other words, to address how people with
AN think as opposed to what they think.
We have shown that people with AN have
difficulties in terms of set shifting and flexi-
bility in their thinking style (1-3). Set shift-
ing has been described as an inability to
change past patterns of thinking and adapt
to new requirements in the environment. In
contrast with healthy individuals, individu-
als with AN show broad set-shifting diffi-
culties both during the acute phase of the
illness and following weight restoration, as
illustrated in our previous research using
longitudinal data (1). The aim of this case
report was to test a module designed to
improve set shifting for a patient with AN.
This module is part of cognitive remedia-
tion therapy (CRT) (4, 5). Generally, CRT
has been used for the treatment of psy-
chosis and people with brain lesions. CRT
programmes for psychosis have consisted
of three major elements: memory, shifting
and planning. The main focus for this case
study was the shifting module, as research
evidence has shown that people with AN
demonstrate inflexibility in information
processing and show increased attention to
detail. Taking the relevant exercises from
available resources (5, 6), we have tailored
and added a number of exercises to our
‘flexibility’ module. Additional exercises
that we have included are visual illusions,
maps and a summarising task (e.g. letters
summarised to bullet points or text mes-
sages). We also emphasized the importance
of ecological validity (i.e. real, every day life
functioning) in our module by encouraging
the patient to reflect on strategies and
thinking styles at the end of every session
and by giving them behavioural tasks to
complete as homework.
In our first case study (7), we found that a
neuropsychological assessment with feed-
back followed by a flexibility module was
beneficial to a patient with AN. The set
shifting tasks were selected to reflect the
different aspect of information processing
ranging from perceptual patterns to the
processing of higher order concepts. These
measures were taken before, after and at
follow-up and it was found that the patient
had improved on half of the tasks.
This was an important finding, as in our
previous longitudinal study on 22 patients
with AN we found that set shifting perfor-
mance did not improve with weight gain
alone and treatment as usual (1). The main
focus in the present case study was: firstly,
to observe if set-shifting training was able to
help a patient with AN increase her flexibili-
ty of thinking, and secondly, to explore the
ecological validity of the procedures by
Ready for press
Return by Fax to n°
02.48.20.12.19
Signature ...................................................................