IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON SIGNAL PROCESSING, VOL. 53, NO. 1, JANUARY 2005 13
Reduced-Rank Adaptive Detection of Distributed
Sources Using Subarrays
Yuanwei Jin, Member, IEEE, and Benjamin Friedlander, Fellow, IEEE
Abstract—We introduce a framework for exploring array detec-
tion problems in a reduced-dimensional space. This involves calcu-
lating a structured subarray transformation matrix for the detec-
tion of a distributed signal using large aperture linear arrays. We
study the performance of the adaptive subarray detector and eval-
uate its potential improvement in detection performance compared
with the full array detector with finite data samples. One would ex-
pect that processing on subarrays may result in performance loss
in that smaller number of degrees of freedom is utilized. However,
it also leads to a better estimation accuracy for the interference and
noise covariance matrix with finite data samples, which will yield
some gain in performance. By studying the subarray detector for
general linear arrays, we identify this gain under various scenarios.
We show that when the number of samples is small, the subarray
detectors have a significant gain over the full array detector. In ad-
dition, the subarray processing can also be successfully applied to
the problem of detecting moving sources in an underwater acoustic
scenario. We validate our results by computer simulations.
Index Terms—Adaptive processing, detection, distributed
source, interference cancellation, reduced rank, subarrays.
INTRODUCTION,BACKGROUND, AND MOTIVATION
T
HE problem of detecting underwater acoustic sources
using measurements by an array of sensors has been
studied extensively in literature. For a large aperture acoustic
array, a narrow beam can be formed so as to distinguish two
closely spaced emitters. However, the acoustic energy source
may be fairly close to the array and may move through several
beams during the sonar system’s temporal integration time. The
effects of source motion on sonar systems have been studied
by several authors (see, for example, [6] and the references
therein). One may model the moving transmitter during an
integration time as a source with energy scattering in space,
which is called a distributed source. The distributed source can
be described by a subspace array manifold model [12].
One of the enduring problems associated with the adaptive
minimum variance distortionless (MVDR) beamformer (see,
e.g., [5] and [10]) lies in the classic dilemma of wanting long
observation times for stable covariance matrix estimates yet
needing short observation times to track dynamic field behavior.
This is especially true for large aperture arrays. This issue has
Manuscript received August 23, 2003; revised January 13, 2004. This work
was supported by the Office of Naval Research under Grant N00014-01-1-0075.
The associate editor coordinating the review of this manuscript and approving
it for publication was Dr. Jean Pierre Delmas.
Y. Jin was with the University of California, Santa Cruz, CA 95060 USA. He
is now with Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213 USA (e-mail:
ywjin@andrew.cmu.edu).
B. Friedlander is with the University of California, Santa Cruz, CA 95060
USA (e-mail: friedlan@cse.ucsc.edu).
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TSP.2004.838941
been addressed by many authors (see, e.g., [6]) and is one of the
research themes of the Acoustic Observatory (AO) Project [1].
There are several ways of dealing with this issue, for in-
stance, the diagonal loading method, which is essentially a
weighted projection method by adding a constant value to each
of the terms along the diagonal of the sample covariance matrix
(see, e.g., [6], [13], and the reference therein). Reduced-rank
processing is another one of the well known data processing
methods (see [4], [11], and the references therein). In this
case, the data are mapped into a lower dimensional subspace
via a transformation matrix prior to detection. Rank-reduction
directly addresses the sample support issue by reducing the
number of statistical unknowns associated with the interference.
In this paper, we study the problem of detecting distributed
sources using subarrays, i.e., a partial collection of sensors of a
full array. In this case, the transformation matrix is a structured
block diagonal matrix.
The motivation for this study lies in the following two
observations. First of all, for a general linear array with
elements, the beam width is inverse proportional to the array
aperture. A subarray with a smaller aperture gives rise to a
wider beam which, consequently, is able to cover the distributed
source if the subarray beamwidth is chosen to be close to the
signal angular spread. Hence, a simple MVDR beamformer
can be implemented on each individual subarray. Second, im-
plementation of a MVDR beamformer requires of estimating
the sample covariance matrix based on data samples. The
estimation accuracy is improved for the subarray processing
compared with the full array processing based on the same
amount of data. This is because we have a smaller amount
of unknown parameters to be estimated. This leads to the fol-
lowing conjecture: With short data records, statistical stability
dominates detector performance, and subarray detection re-
quires substantially less SNR than full array processing. With
large data records, SNR dominates detection performance, and
the subarray detector requires nearly the same SNR as the full
array detector. Hence, substantial performance improvements
are possible using the subarray detector relative to the full
array detector in limited-data situations.
It should be noted that the idea of subarray processing has
been proposed before and has been studied by several authors,
for instance, Cox [8], Morgan [14], Owsley and Swingler [19],
and Dhanatawari [9]. Owsley suggested that a narrow band uni-
form linear array (ULA) containing elements could be de-
composed into, say, nonoverlapped but contiguous subarrays
of equal length. Each subarray is operated as a simple delay and
sum beamformer and the output from each is treated in exactly
the same fashion as the output from a single sensor in a ULA
1053-587X/$20.00 © 2005 IEEE