RESEARCH AND ANALYSIS
Efficiency Through Proximity
Changes in Phosphorus Cycling at the Urban–Agricultural
Interface of a Rapidly Urbanizing Desert Region
Genevi` eve Metson, Rimjhim Aggarwal, and Daniel L. Childers
Summary
In tightly coupled socioecological systems, such as cities, the interactions between socio-
economic and biophysical characteristics of an area strongly influence ecosystem function.
Very often the effects of socioeconomic activities on ecosystem function are unintended,
but can impact the sustainability of a city and can have irreversible effects. The food system
in its entirety, from production to treatment of human waste, is one of the most important
contributors to the way phosphorus (P) cycles through cities. In this article we examined
the changes in P dynamics at the urban–agricultural interface of the Phoenix, Arizona, USA,
metropolitan area between 1978 and 2008. We found that the contribution of cotton to
harvested P decreased while the contribution of alfalfa, which is used as feed for local dairy
cows, increased over the study period. This change in cropping pattern was accompanied by
growth in the dairy industry and increased internal recycling of P due to dairy cow manure
application to alfalfa fields and the local recycling of biosolids and treated wastewater. The
proximity of urban populations with dairies and feed production and low runoff in this arid
climate have facilitated this serendipitous recycling. Currently P is not strongly regulated or
intentionally managed in this system, but farmers’ behaviors, shaped largely by market forces
and policies related to water recycling, unintentionally affect P cycling. This underscores the
need to move from unintentional to deliberate and holistic management of P dynamics
through collaborations between practitioners and researchers in order to enhance urban
sustainability.
Keywords:
biosolids
industrial ecology
manure
Phoenix
sustainability
urban ecology
Supporting information is available
on the JIE Web site
Introduction
Phosphorus (P) is an essential nutrient for all living or-
ganisms and is often the limiting nutrient in agricultural soils
(meaning that the growth of plants is often limited by the
amount of P available to them) (Chapin et al. 2002; Drech-
sel et al. 2001; Pierrou 1979; Runge-Metzger 1995). Both P
and nitrogen (N), another nutrient, are building blocks of all
organisms and cycle through ecosystems in both their organic
and inorganic forms (via organisms, water, air, etc.). However,
while the majority of N is found as N
2
gas, which is fixed by
plants and subsequently incorporated into other organic and in-
Address correspondence to: Genevieve Metson, Department of Natural Resource Science, McGill University, 111 Lackeshore Road, Ste. Anne de Bellevue, QC H9X 3V9,
Canada. Email: genevieve.metson@mail.mcgill.ca
© 2012 by Yale University
DOI: 10.1111/j.1530-9290.2012.00554.x
Volume 16, Number 6
organic complexes, P follows a mineral, sedimentary cycle. That
is, the majority of P is found in mineral form, which weathers
so that P can be incorporated into organic materials, and even-
tually returned to sediments. On shorter time scales, P is also
recycled within ecosystems as animal and plant waste to soils
where it is taken up again.
Modern agricultural systems depend on mined P for fertilizer
to maintain high crop yields, and the production of fertilizer
is the most important cause of human alteration of the global
P cycle (Smil 2000; Turner 1990). Of the 160 million tons of
phosphate rock currently extracted per year, 90% is for fertilizer
production, making agriculture, and the food chain that follows,
914 Journal of Industrial Ecology www.wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/jie