On the Mechanism for Nitrate Formation via the Peroxy Radical + NO Reaction
Jieyuan Zhang,
²
Tim Dransfield,
‡
and Neil M. Donahue*
,§
Departments of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Carnegie Mellon UniVersity,
Pittsburgh, PennsylVania 15213, and HarVard UniVersity, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138
ReceiVed: May 3, 2004; In Final Form: August 4, 2004
We present a master equation study of organic nitrate formation from the peroxy radical (RO
2
) + NO reaction.
The mechanism is constrained by both quantum chemical calculations of the potential energy surface and
existing yield data. This mechanism displays heretofore unrecognized features of the system, including distinct
conformers of a critical peroxynitrite (ROONO) intermediate that do not interconvert and a dual falloff behavior
driven by collisional stabilization in multiple wells. These features have significant implications for atmospheric
chemistry; in particular, only a fraction of the ROONO intermediates may easily isomerize to nitrates, resulting
in a limit to total nitrate production. Existing mechanisms, extrapolated to low temperature and high pressure,
produce nitrate almost exclusively. As a consequence, hydrocarbon oxidation sequences based on these
mechanisms do not propagate radical chemistry, which is inconsistent with available experimental data. To
reproduce observed nitrate yields, we model a transition state from the ROONO intermediate to RONO
2
that
differs considerably from the few found in computational studies. Specifically, the data require that this transition
state energy lie well below the energy of separated radical products (RO + NO
2
), while computational studies
find the transition state at higher energies. A second feature of yield data is difficult to model; to enable
collisional stabilization of C
5
systems, as observed, we reduce the unimolecular decomposition rate constants
from the ROONO intermediate by a factor that is at the far end of the plausible range. However, with these
experimental constraints in place, the model successfully reproduces multiple features of existing data
quantitatively, including both high- and low-pressure asymptotes to nitrate production as well as the observed
shifting of pressure falloff curves with carbon number. Consequently, we present a new parametrization of
nitrate yields, providing interpolation equivalent to existing parametrizations but dramatically improved
extrapolation behavior.
1. Introduction
If one heretofore unobserVed reaction intermediate cannot
explain published data, why not inVoke two?
The reaction of peroxy radicals (RO
2
) with nitric oxide (NO)
sits in the very center of atmospheric chemistry. On one hand,
it may yield radical products, alkoxy radicals (RO) and NO
2
,
effectively producing ozone after NO
2
photolysis. On the other
hand, it may yield nitrates (RONO
2
), effectively terminating
the radical chain reaction in the atmosphere. It is widely accepted
that both channels share a common intermediate, a peroxy nitrite
(ROONO), whose subsequent decomposition governs the branch-
ing between radicals and nitrate, as shown in the following
sequence:
1,2
What has not been recognized is that two generally distinct
conformers of the ROONO intermediate have quite separate
chemical behaviors and fates. We will refer to these conformers
as cis- and trans-ROONO (describing the O-O-N-O con-
formation). In particular, the isomerization between these two
forms is quite slow, compared to the other reactions open to
each conformer, and only one conformer can easily isomerize
to become a nitrate. Thus one conformer connects only to the
radical products, while the other connects to both radicals and
nitrates. We shall argue that this easily isomerized ROONO is
the trans form, though the only important conclusion is that the
conformers behave differently. The first purpose of this paper
is to establish this assertion and to discuss its implications.
The second purpose of this paper is to build the case that the
observed pressure dependence for nitrate yields (for all but the
very smallest species) is due to the collisional stabilization of
these ROONO intermediates and their subsequent, rapid, thermal
decomposition. Nitrate yields are thus controlled by three
factors: (1) the initial branching of the RO
2
+ NO reaction
between cis- and trans-ROONO; (2) the ratio of nitrate to radical
formation for trans-ROONO at high (reactant) energy (which
controls the low-pressure production of nitrate); and (3) the
critical energy difference between the nitrate and radical
pathways out of trans-ROONO (which controls the high-
pressure limit and the temperature dependence of nitrate
formation). An intriguing consequence of this is that the puzzling
variation of nitrate yields among different classes of peroxy
radicals (primary, secondary, and tertiary alkyl-peroxy
3
; -hy-
droxy-peroxy radicals
4-7
) may be governed in large measure
by the initial branching between cis- and trans-ROONO.
* To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: nmd@
andrew.cmu.edu.
²
Carnegie Mellon University, Department of Chemical Engineering.
‡
Harvard University, Department of Chemistry and Chemical Biology.
§
Carnegie Mellon University, Department of Chemistry.
RO
2
+ NO f ROONO (1)
ROONO f RO + NO
2
(2)
f RONO
2
(3)
9082 J. Phys. Chem. A 2004, 108, 9082-9095
10.1021/jp048096x CCC: $27.50 © 2004 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 09/25/2004