133
Neotropical Ichthyology, 10(1): 133-147, 2012
Copyright © 2012 Sociedade Brasileira de Ictiologia
Fishermen’s local ecological knowledge on Southeastern Brazilian coastal
fishes: contributions to research, conservation, and management
Renato A. M. Silvano
1,4
and Alpina Begossi
2,3,4
We analyzed fishermen’s local ecological knowledge (LEK) about the feeding habits, trophic interactions, habitats, fishing
grounds, migration, and reproduction of nine coastal fishes in Búzios Island, southeastern Brazilian coast. We interviewed 39
fishermen using standardized questionnaires. Fishermen’s LEK on habitat use and trophic interactions for the studied fishes
agreed with the scientific literature, allowing the organization of reef and pelagic food webs. The interviewed fishermen
mentioned that submerged rock formations would be important habitats for some large commercial fishes, such as Seriola
spp., Caranx latus and Epinephelus marginatus. In some instances there was no scientific data to be compared with fishermen’s
LEK, and thus this kind of knowledge would be the only available source of information, such as for reproduction and
migration of most of the studied fishes. We suggest herein ways to apply fishermen’s LEK to develop and improve fisheries
management measures, such as zoning of marine space, marine protected areas, and closed fishing seasons. Fishermen’s LEK
may be an important and feasible support to fisheries management and co-management.
Analisamos o conhecimento ecológico local (CEL) dos pescadores sobre os hábitos alimentares, interações tróficas, habitats,
locais de pesca, migração e reprodução de nove peixes costeiros na Ilha de Búzios, litoral sudeste do Brasil. Entrevistamos 39
pescadores, utilizando questionários padronizados. As informações sobre uso do habitat e interações tróficas entre os peixes
estudados com base no CEL dos pescadores foram condizentes com a literatura científica, permitindo a organização de teias
tróficas para os habitats recifal e pelágico. Os pescadores entrevistados mencionaram que formações de rochas submersas
seriam habitats importantes para alguns peixes comerciais de grande porte, como Seriola spp., Caranx latus e Epinephelus
marginatus. Em algumas circunstâncias, não haviam dados biológicos para serem comparados com o CEL dos pescadores,
que, portanto seria a única fonte disponível de informação, por exemplo sobre a reprodução e migração de vários dos peixes
estudados. Sugerimos aqui formas de aplicar o CEL dos pescadores para desenvolver e aprimorar medidas de manejo pesqueiro,
como zoneamento do espaço marinho, áreas marinhas protegidas e épocas de defeso da pesca. O CEL dos pescadores pode
ser um apoio importante e factível para iniciativas de manejo e co-manejo pesqueiro.
Key words: Ethnobiology, Fish behavior, Fish ecology, Human ecology, Small-scale fisheries.
1
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Departamento de Ecologia, CP 15007, 91501-970 Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil.
renato.silvano@ufrgs.br
2
Universidade Santa Cecília/UNISANTA, ECOMAR, 11045-040 Santos, SP, Brazil.
3
Universidade de Campinas, CAPESCA, PREAC & CMU, Rua Sergio Buarque de Holanda 800, Cidade Universitária, CP 6023, 13083-
859, Campinas, SP, Brazil, alpinab@uol.com.br
4
Universidade de Santa Cecília/UNISANTA, Fisheries and Food Institute (FIFO), 11045-040 Santos, SP, Brazil.
Introduction
In order to deal with increasingly environmental
uncertainties and complex, multi-species fisheries, fisheries
management should ideally be ecosystem based, adaptive
and precautionary, being implemented even if managers have
incomplete biological data (Johannes, 1998; Pauly et al., 2002).
Many tropical developing countries lack the scientific
information needed to manage coastal fisheries. These
fisheries may have thus to be managed following a “data
less” approach, which includes all available biological data
plus inputs from fishermen’s local ecological knowledge (LEK)
(Johannes, 1998). Indeed, several studies have been analyzing
fisher’s LEK and comparing it with available scientific
ecological research; these studies contribute to improve the
knowledge about ecology, migration, reproduction, feeding
habits, and changes in abundance of a diverse array of fishing
resources, ranging from fish to whales (Johannes, 1981; Poizat
& Baran, 1997; Johannes et al., 2000; Huntington et al., 2004;
Sa’enz-Arroyo et al., 2005; Silvano et al., 2008, 2009).
Therefore, studies on fishers’ LEK may be useful to develop
new and testable biological hypotheses (Silvano & Valbo-