Full length article
Temptations of fluency and dilemmas of self definition: Stutterers'
usage and avoidance of new media technologies
Hananel Rosenberg
a, b, *
, Ayelet Kohn
c
a
Department of Communication, Ariel University, Israel
b
Department of Communication, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel
c
The Department of Communications, David Yellin Academic College of Education, Jerusalem, Israel
article info
Article history:
Received 9 September 2015
Received in revised form
22 March 2016
Accepted 1 April 2016
Keywords:
Forums
New media
Social media avoidance
Technology use
Mobile phones
Verbal fluency disorders
abstract
Media technologies, such as telephones, often challenge stammers. Other media, especially applications
such as SMS and social networks, enable stammers to express themselves fluently. This study looks into
the multifaceted meanings of the encounter between stammers and new media, focusing on applications
which enable speech through writing, and a Stammers forum website, as a site for reflexive debate on the
meaning of new media opportunities. The study focuses on questions such as anonymity, the “noise” of
various media and the ways in which new media helps to improve the users quality of life, but at the
same time might lead them to reduce their social life to an alternative “verbal ghetto”, confined to the
borders of the new media platform.
© 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Tom Hooper's The King's Speech (hereinafter: “TKS”)
1
brought
short-lived pleasure to stutterers, or to use the clinical terminology,
those suffering from verbal fluency disorders (hereinafter:
“VFDs”).
2
After years of VFD sufferers suffering the further insult of
being mocked and portrayed as laughingstocks by Hollywood
(Johnson, 2008), the motion picture industry presented a “royal
narrative” of stuttering in King George VI's struggle with a lifelong
speech impediment that he could no longer hide in the royal palace
due to the rise of a new mass medium d radio d that required him
to speak clearly and fluently. Communication technologies
occasionally present challenges and difficulties to stutterers that
are amplified during use, depending upon each medium's unique
character (James, Brumfitt, & Cudd, 1999). At the same time, some
communication technologies, particularly the range of applications
in the new media, constitute an opportunity for “stutter bypass”,
and a new type of fluency, for those for whom fluency constitutes a
constant obstacle to self-expression. In this study, we present the
varied implications of the encounter between the stutterer and
new media, focusing on the various speech and writing applica-
tions available, and on the online Israeli Tapúz Stutterers' Forum as
a locus of reflexive discourse on this matter and as a test case for
these uses.
The Stutterers' Forum serves as a fascinating site for reflexive
debate on the meaning of new media opportunities. While liber-
ating its users from their difficulties to conduct a fluent conversa-
tion, it might lead its participants to reduce their social life to an
alternative “verbal ghetto”, confined to the borders of the new
media platform. This contradiction leads us to characterize the
stutterers' forum as a multi-functional site for its participants: as a
host of a support group, as a site which enables its users to gain
their voice back, as an opportunity to discuss the place of new
media in the life of people with impairments on a whole, and as a
site of self reflection about stutterers and their relationships with
* Corresponding author. Communication and Journalism Department, The He-
brew University of Jerusalem, Mount Scopus, Jerusalem 9190501, Israel.
E-mail addresses: hananelro@gmail.com (H. Rosenberg), ayeletkohn@gmail.com
(A. Kohn).
1
The King's Speech (2010): T. Hooper (Dir.), I. Caning, E. Sherman, & G. Unwin
(Prods.). UK Film Council.
2
The terms “stammer”/“stutter” and “stutterer”, which we shall expand upon
later further on, are used herein for ease in reading, and do not reflect a dehu-
manization or rejection of the subjects of this study. In parallel, the choice to use
these terms actually demonstrates the daily encounter with image-based diffi-
culties that VFD sufferers face every time they open their mouths.
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Computers in Human Behavior
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/comphumbeh
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.chb.2016.04.008
0747-5632/© 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Computers in Human Behavior 62 (2016) 536e544