Scanning Electrochemical Microscopy. 43. Investigation of Oxalate Oxidation and
Electrogenerated Chemiluminescence across the Liquid-Liquid Interface
²
Fre ´ de ´ ric Kanoufi,
‡,§
Ce ´ line Cannes,
‡
Yanbing Zu,
‡
and Allen J. Bard*
,‡
Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, The UniVersity of Texas at Austin, Austin, Texas 78712, and
Laboratoire EnVironnement et Chimie Analytique, ESPCI, 10 rue Vauquelin, 75231 Paris Cedex 05, France
ReceiVed: March 7, 2001; In Final Form: June 15, 2001
To treat the problem of oxalate oxidation in an aqueous phase by a Ru(III) species (mediator) generated in
an immiscible nonaqueous phase (benzonitrile) at a scanning electrochemical microscope (SECM tip), the
theory of the feedback mode of the SECM is extended to include both finite heterogeneous electron transfer
(ET) kinetics at the substrate and homogeneous decomposition of the mediator. As for the classical
electrochemical (EC) scheme, a zone diagram is constructed showing pure ET heterogeneous kinetic control,
pure homogeneous kinetic (C) control (insulating behavior), and mixed EC kinetic control. The model allows
interpretation of the anomalous approach curves obtained for oxalate oxidation by a ruthenium(III) coordination
complex at the benzonitrile (BN)-water interface and allows calculation of the rate constant for the ET at
the liquid-liquid interface. Attempts are made to relate these rates to the homogeneous rate constant in terms
of Marcus theory. The second ET (oxidation of CO
2
•
-
) at the liquid-liquid interface generates an emitting
excited state of the ruthenium species. The electrogenerated chemiluminescence process is related to the
current crossing the interface.
Introduction
Electron transfer (ET) reactions at the liquid-liquid interface
have been extensively investigated over the past 20 years
1
owing, in part, to interest in the liquid-liquid interface as an
intermediate case between homogeneous and heterogeneous sites
for ET.
2
Several different models have been developed to depict
the ET at the interface between two immiscible electrolyte
solutions (ITIES).
3-6
Among the various techniques used to probe ET at an ITIES
(e.g., cyclic voltammetry
1
or voltfluorometry
7-9
in a four-
electrode cell, voltammetry in a thin-layer cell
10
), the scanning
electrochemical microscope (SECM) in its feedback mode has
been shown to be particularly useful in the characterization of
ET kinetics.
11-19
The SECM technique has the advantage of
easy separation of the contribution of electron transfer and ion
transfer processes and does not require a four-electrode arrange-
ment with an externally applied potential across the interface.
Typically in these experiments, a stable redox active species,
for example an oxidant, is generated at an ultramicroelectrode
(UME) tip located in one liquid phase and the tip is approached
to the second liquid that contains another redox species, a
reductant, that can transfer an electron to the tip-generated
oxidant. The tip feedback current depends on the rate of this
electron transfer. In most studies this oxidant is part of a stable
redox couple, thus simplifying the treatment of the kinetics and
mechanism of the system. However, the SECM technique can
also be used to investigate the kinetics of irreversible ET at an
ITIES, such as the reduction of dibromocyclohexane by vitamin
B
12
.
20
Such studies of electrochemical catalysis are of interest
in characterizing syntheses in microemulsions. Moreover, in
principle, they should provide interesting information by
comparing the ET rates to their homogeneous analogues in terms
of ET theory.
Previous reports from this laboratory have shown that
oxidation of a luminophor such as RuL
2
L′
2+
in the presence
of a coreactant, such as the oxalate dianion, leads to the
formation of an excited state [electrogenerated chemilumines-
cence (ECL)], by homogeneous reaction in the aqueous
phase,
21,22
either at a polymer-modified electrode,
23
or at an
ITIES.
24
This latter study qualitatively demonstrated ECL at
the ITIES and proposed that its occurrence was evidence of
Marcus inverted region behavior. This paper is a more detailed
and quantitative study of this type of ET and ECL reaction.
Based on the observation of ECL at the BN-water interface
and on the homogeneous
22
or electrochemical
25
oxidation of
oxalate, a mechanism of the ECE type, depicted in Scheme 1
and schematically presented in Figure 1 in the SECM config-
uration, can be invoked for the SECM monitored oxalate
²
Part of the special issue “Royce W. Murray Festschrift”.
‡
The University of Texas at Austin.
§
ESPCI.
SCHEME 1
8951 J. Phys. Chem. B 2001, 105, 8951-8962
10.1021/jp0108667 CCC: $20.00 © 2001 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 08/10/2001