Journal of Natural Gas Chemistry 20(2011)603–610
Fuzzy model prediction of Co (III)/Al
2
O
3
catalytic behavior
in Fischer-Tropsch synthesis
Mohammad Ali Takassi
1
, Mahdi Koolivand Salooki
2∗
, Morteza Esfandyari
3
1. Department of Science, Petroleum College, Petroleum University of Technology, Ahvaz 6198144471, Iran;
2. Oil & Gas Processing Center of Excellence, Chemical Engineering Department, University of Tehran, 11155-4563, Tehran, Iran;
3. Department of Chemical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Ferdowsi University of Mashad, P.O.Box1111 Mashad, Iran
[ Manuscript received December 24, 2010; revised March 12, 2011 ]
Abstract
The application of Co (III)/Al
2
O
3
catalyst in Fischer-Tropsch synthesis (FTS) was studied in a wide range of synthesis gas conversions and
compared with Fuzzy Simulation results. Present study applies fuzzy model to predicting the product composition of CH
4
, CO
2
and CO in
Fischer-Tropsch process for natural gas synthesis, in which the input vector was 4-dimension including four variables (operating pressure,
operating temperature, time and CO/H
2
ratio) of 70 different experiments and the output product is a composition of CO
2
, CO and CH
4
.
The Mamdani algorithm has been applied to the training of the fuzzy system and the test set was used to evaluate the performance of the
system including R
2
, ARE, AARE and SD. The results demonstrated that the predicted values from the model were in good consistency with
the experimental data. The work indicates how fuzzy inference system (FIS), as a promising predicting technique, would be effectively used
in FTS.
Key words
fuzzy inference system; Fischer-Tropsch; natural gas; catalyst; Co (III); Al
2
O
3
1. Introduction
Fischer-Tropsch synthesis (FTS) is an interesting and
promising pathway for the conversion of synthesis gas to
transportation fuels. FTS has been recognized as an important
alternate technology to petroleum refining in the production
of liquid fuels and chemicals from syngas derived from coal,
natural gas and other carbon-containing materials [1-3]. Sev-
eral metals (including Fe, Co, Ni and Ru) are considered as
the most common active components for FTS catalysts, due
to their high FTS activity, low cost, flexible product distribu-
tion and favorable engineering characteristics [4].
Owing to high activity and long durability, cobalt-based
FT catalysts are currently a choice for the conversion of syn-
gas to natural gas and liquid fuels. In addition, they provide
the best compromise between reduced costs and the high CO
conversion.
Cobalt based catalysts offer favorable C
5+
selectivity as
well as low water gas shift (WGS) activity for the synthesis
of liquid fuels from natural gas. Supported Co catalysts with
high specific rates require the synthesis of small metal crys-
tallites at high local surface densities on the support, those
of supports or alloys that increase the rate per surface Co
(turnover rate) [5,6,7].
The FTS and WGS reactions are as follows:
CO + (1 + n/2) H
2
→ CH
n
+H
2
O
CO + H
2
O → CO
2
+H
2
where, n is the average H/C ratio of the produced hydrocar-
bons. Xiong et al. [8] reported that the FTS activity and se-
lectivity of cobalt based catalysts could be affected by their
pore sizes. Song et al. [9] also indicated that the pore size of
alumina support could significantly influence the Co
3
O
4
crys-
tallite diameter, catalyst reducibility and FT activity. So in our
experiment we have used Co based catalyst.
Often knowledge base precise modeling methods are not
suitable for the complex systems due to the lack of precise
knowledge about these systems, nonlinear behavior and time
varying characteristics of them. This limitation introduces a
tendency to modeling complex systems based on intelligent
methods, such as neural networks and fuzzy modeling. There
are many researches in various fields that used these methods
in nonlinear system identification. The neural networks have
been applied in modeling the green house effect, simulating
N
2
O emissions from a temperate grassland ecosystem, and
assessing flotation experiments [10-12]. Mastorocostas et al.
∗
Corresponding author. Tel/Fax: +98-918-3532398; E-mail: Koolivand.m@nisoc. ir
Copyright©2011, Dalian Institute of Chemical Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/S1003-9953(10)60240-X