LETTERS
Label-free immunodetection with CMOS-compatible
semiconducting nanowires
Eric Stern
1
, James F. Klemic
2
, David A. Routenberg
2
, Pauline N. Wyrembak
5
, Daniel B. Turner-Evans
2
,
Andrew D. Hamilton
5
, David A. LaVan
3
, Tarek M. Fahmy
1
& Mark A. Reed
2,4
Semiconducting nanowires have the potential to function as
highly sensitive and selective sensors for the label-free detection
of low concentrations of pathogenic microorganisms
1–10
. Suc-
cessful solution-phase nanowire sensing has been demonstrated
for ions
3
, small molecules
4
, proteins
5,6
, DNA
7
and viruses
8
; how-
ever, ‘bottom-up’ nanowires (or similarly configured carbon
nanotubes
11
) used for these demonstrations require hybrid fab-
rication schemes
12,13
, which result in severe integration issues that
have hindered widespread application. Alternative ‘top-down’
fabrication methods of nanowire-like devices
9,10,14–17
produce dis-
appointing performance because of process-induced material and
device degradation. Here we report an approach that uses comple-
mentary metal oxide semiconductor (CMOS) field effect transistor
compatible technology and hence demonstrate the specific
label-free detection of below 100 femtomolar concentrations of
antibodies as well as real-time monitoring of the cellular immune
response. This approach eliminates the need for hybrid methods
and enables system-scale integration of these sensors with signal
processing and information systems. Additionally, the ability to
monitor antibody binding and sense the cellular immune response
in real time with readily available technology should facilitate
widespread diagnostic applications.
We demonstrate here that the limitations of fabricated nanowire-
type devices can be overcome and that nanometre-scale sensors with
little mobility degradation from bulk can be achieved. We have used
ultrathin silicon-on-insulator wafers
9,10,18,19
, which require only lat-
eral (in-plane, two-dimensional) active layer definition to achieve the
nanometre dimensions needed for a nanowire-type device. Previous
attempts with this approach used reactive-ion etching (RIE) of the
active silicon layer, which unacceptably degraded device perform-
ance
9,10
. To achieve the nanometre-scale dimensions necessary for
sensitivity, we developed a fabrication process using an anisotropic
wet etch: specifically, tetramethylammonium hydroxide, TMAH,
which etches Si (111) planes about 100 times more slowly than all
other planes
20
. This approach allows retention of pattern definition
(of a masking oxide layer), and smoothes edge imperfections not
aligned to the (111) plane. Previous work on TMAH-defined elec-
tronic devices has shown excellent retention of electrical properties
18
,
although not in configurations suitable for sensing. We show that
‘nanowire’ devices capable of sensing can be defined by TMAH etch-
ing. Our approach uses commercially available (100) silicon-on-
insulator wafers that yield trapezoidal cross-section nanowires with
dominant Si (111) exposed planes, the preferred surface for selective
surface functionalization
21
.
First, we show that this process can be used reproducibly to gen-
erate non-degraded devices that are narrower than their lithographic
pattern definition
19
. A schematic depicting a completed device before
removal of the masking oxide is shown in Fig. 1a. The anisotropic wet
etch undercuts this masking oxide, whose lateral dimensions can be
achieved with optical lithography, although it does not appreciably
etch the degenerately doped (.10
20
cm
23
) boron contacts
20
. A top-
view scanning electron micrograph of a device with the oxide mask
1
Department of Biomedical Engineering,
2
Department of Electrical Engineering,
3
Department of Mechanical Engineering,
4
Department of Applied Physics, Yale University, P O Box
208284 New Haven, Connecticut 06511, USA.
5
Department of Chemistry, Yale University, P O Box 208107, New Haven, Connecticut 06511, USA.
t
S
D
G
w
a
200 nm
b
c
e
0
300
Mobility (cm
2
V
–1
s
–1
)
100
50
0
0 –10 –20 –30 –40
–5 –10 –15
10 μm
I
SD
(10
–6
A)
|I
SD
(A)|
V
SD
(V)
V
GD
(V)
30 100 300
Temperature (K)
Hall
Drift
–1
–2
10
–7
10
–9
10
–11
10
–13
10
–15
–3
d
f
Figure 1 | Device fabrication and electrical performance. a, Schematic after
anisotropic etch. The silicon-on-insulator active channel (yellow, width w
and thickness t) is undercut etched, whereas degenerate leads (red) are etch-
resistant. The source (S), drain (D), and underlying backgate (G) are
labelled. b, c, Scanning electron micrograph (b) and optical micrograph (c) of
a completed device. d, I
SD
(V
SD
)(w 5 50nm, t 5 25nm) for varying V
GD
(0 to
240 V, DV 521 V), illustrating p-type accumulation mode behaviour.
e, | I
SD
| (V
GD
) for V
SD
521 V for forward (red) and reverse (black) sweep.
f, Accumulation-mode Hall and drift mobilities versus temperature
(w 5 300 nm, t 5 25 nm).
Vol 445 | 1 February 2007 | doi:10.1038/nature05498
519
Nature ©2007 Publishing Group