Plant Ecology 139: 247–258, 1998.
© 1998 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
247
Effects of pollution on the nutrient return via litterfall for Pinus radiata
plantations in the Basque Country
A. Gonz´ alez-Arias
1
, I. Amezaga
1
, A. Echeand´ ıa
1
, M. Domingo
2
& M. Onaindia
1
1
Dep. Biolog´ ıa Vegetal y Ecolog´ ıa, Universidad del Pa´ ıs Vasco/EHU, Apdo. 644, 48080 Bilbao, Spain;
2
Servicio
de Investigaci´ on y Mejora Agraria (SIMA), Derio, Bizkaia, Spain
Received 10 July 1997; accepted in revised form 31 July 1998
Key words: Cycling of nutrients, Litterfall, Nutrient return, Nutrient Use Efficiencies, Pinus radiata, Pollution
Abstract
The effects of atmospheric pollution on two 10 year old Pinus radiata D. Don forests (Manzanal and Posadero)
was studied in the Basque country, analysing the concentration of different nutrients and nutrient input via litterfall.
Litterfall production peaked in autumn, and 97.5% of the litterfall consisted of pine needles at Posadero (the
less-polluted area), whereas this figure was found to be 88.6% at Manzanal (the polluted area). Posadero had
a higher production of litterfall than Manzanal due to the higher tree density. Nutrient concentration showed a
similar seasonal variation over the year at both sites. Pine litterfall in the polluted area, Manzanal, had significantly
higher concentrations of iron, copper, zinc, sulphur, calcium, sodium and magnesium than in Posadero, while the
concentrations of nitrogen, phosphorous and potassium did not differ between sites. Calcium, sodium, magnesium,
sulphur, iron and copper input to the forest via litterfall was significantly higher for the polluted area, but the
inputs of nitrogen, phosphorous, potassium and zinc did not significantly differ between sites. Both sites showed
high nutrient use efficiencies for phosphorous and calcium compared with other coniferous forests. The highest
efficiency was for phosphorous, possibly due to the low availability of this ion in the soil. Trees at Posadero were
consistently more efficient for calcium than at Manzanal due to the effect of pollution on the latter site. Molar
ratios between aluminium and the basic cation nutrients calcium and magnesium in soil were higher at the polluted
area, as a result of the increased inputs of anions to the forest soil (Al:Ca = 1.9:1 and Al:Mg = 6.9:1 at Posadero
and Al:Ca = 5.7:1 and Al:Mg = 14:1 at Manzanal). The current pollution level of Manzanal is leading to a loss of
cations that may cause future changes in the functioning of this forest.
Introduction
Due to the death of forests in industrialised countries
during the last 2 decades, numerous studies have been
carried out to evaluate the effect that acidic ion deposi-
tion has on nutrient cycling in forest ecosystems (e.g.,
Rehfuess 1981; Ulrich 1984; Bredemeier 1988; Mu-
rach & Matzner 1988; Smith 1990; Tomlinson 1990;
Kratz 1991; Capellato et al. 1993; Onaindia et al.
1995; Gjengedal 1996; Amezaga et al. 1997). There
are two main groups of air pollutants, those emitted
directly into the atmosphere such as sulphur dioxide,
carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides and hydrocarbons
and those produced through reactions between pri-
mary pollutants and normal atmospheric compounds.
Sulphur oxides, mainly sulphur dioxide, and nitrogen
dioxide are the main pollutants derived from human
activities.
Sulphur dioxide is emitted primarily from station-
ary sources, such as power plants that burn fossil fuels,
whereas nitrogen oxides are emitted from both station-
ary and transport-related sources. In the atmosphere,
sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxide are transformed
by reactions with oxygen and water vapour to form
sulphuric and nitric acids (Botkin & Keller 1995).
During the 1960’s monitoring stations for the collec-
tion and analysis of rain and snow were established in
North America and Europe. It was apparent that sul-
phuric and nitric acids were present in the precipitation
falling over large areas (Tomlinson 1990).