Introduction
Clinical simulations enable experiential learning.
Their use provides learners with a safe
environment conducive to learning without fear
of personal failure or compromising client
welfare. In addition, they promote control over
learning so facilitating independence and skill
development (Conrick et al. 1996, Roberts et al.
1992). Nurse educators and researchers, however,
have indicated they need further understanding
of the development of clinical simulations
(Mailloux 1998, Roberts 2000). This paper
presents both a conceptual and applied approach
to simulation development and validation.
Simulations and learning
Simulations can facilitate a learning process that
is active and mimics clinical reality. In this
learning process the learner has the opportunity
to experience dimensions of clinical practice
vicariously. Hence, simulations bridge the reality
gap bringing miniaturized versions of some
sphere of real life activity into the learning
environment (Inbar & Stoll 1972). Such
applications can be considered a foundation for
learning that is deep (Ramsden 1992) and
transformative (Bains 1994). Higgs (1992) argues
simulations promote learning for understanding
and meaning rather than rote learning of facts
and principles. This does not replace real clinical
experience but it does extend the subject matter to
equip learners with some skills that can be
directly transferred into the ‘real’ clinical setting
(Edwards et al. 1995). Practice situations created
by simulations can result in learners gaining
increased self-confidence and improved clinical
judgement (Thiele et al. 1991). A structured focus
on the learning process in this way encourages
learner self-monitoring, has the potential to be
integrated into clinical tasks and can promote
deliberation about specific aspects of practice.
Learning situations involving simulations can
be accompanied by other strategies such as
‘thinking aloud’ (Cocoran et al. 1988) and critical
Article
© 2001 Harcourt Publishers Ltd Nurse Education Today (2001) 21, 477–486 477
Clinical simulations:
development and validation
Jane Cioffi
Jane Cioffi RN,
BApp Sc, (Adv
Nsg), Grad Dip Ed,
MApp Sc (Nsg)
PhD. Faculty of
Health, University
of Western Sydney,
Locked Bag #1, PO
Richmond 2753,
Australia. E-mail:
j.cioffi@uws.edu.au
Fax: 0245701420;
Tel.: 0245701929
Manuscript
accepted: 13 March
2001
Published online:
15 June 2001
Simulations used as an educational strategy can mimic clinical reality bringing real life activity
into the learning environment. This paper presents a conceptual approach to simulation
development and validation that is applied to develop assessment simulations for both
childbirth and triage situations. A process-based method of presenting information to the
learner in the assessment phase is incorporated in simulations developed from actual clinical
cases. The uncertain conditions of assessment are recognized as mirroring practice reality and
validation of this construct and that of expertise are considered. Use of these simulations has
the potential to provide learners with the opportunity to experience dimensions of simulated
practice reality and educators with an experiential strategy that can be used to prepare students
and also clinicians who are unfamiliar with new clinical practice areas. © 2001 Harcourt
Publishers Ltd
doi:10.1054/nedt.2001.0584, available online at http://www.idealibrary.com on