Experimental Validation of a Dynamic model of a SRM used in
superconducting bearing flywheel energy storage system
J.L. SILVA NETO
1
, R. DE ANDRADE Jr
1,2
,
L.G.B. ROLIM
1,2
, A.C. FERREIRA
1,2
, G. G. SOTELO
2
, W. SUEMITSU
1,2
1
Department of Electrical Engineering,
2
COPPE/Electrical Engineering Program
Federal University of Rio de Janeiro
P.O.Box 68504, CEP 21941-972
BRAZIL
luizneto@dee.ufrj.br , ferreira@ufrj.br , rolim@dee.ufrj.br
Abstract: - This paper presents a dynamic model of a
flywheel energy storage system with
superconducting magnetic axial thrust bearing
(SMB) and a permanent magnet radial bearing
(PMB), which uses a switched reluctance machine
(SRM) as motor/generator. The SMB was built with
Nd-Fe-B magnet and YBCO superconducting blocks,
refrigerated with liquid nitrogen. The developed
model can take SRM non-linearities into account, by
including the inductances as a function of the
angular position and phase current. Simulations of
the power electronics and SRM show that the system
can work up to 30,000 rpm supplying the required
energy during disturbances. The control and power
circuitry are described. An experimental validation
of the model is performed.
Key-Words: - flywheel, superconducting magnetic
bearings, switched reluctance machine, energy
storage.
1. Introduction
In modern production plants, momentaneous voltage
disturbances, such as voltage sags, can cause slow
output, production interruption or damage to machines.
Energy customers with continuous process involving
fragile materials, like paper forming, food processing,
etc, are likely to avoid prejudices with interruptions due
to the energy quality problems. In order to mitigate
voltage sags dynamic voltage restorers can regulate the
voltage at the load bar avoiding the prejudices, but some
of these devices draw the energy necessary to
compensate the voltage sags from the same grid that they
will compensate. This strategy can cause a system failure
in some cases. In order to avoid this failure, these
equipments may employ energy storage devices as
electrochemical batteries and flywheels [1].
The above reasons have motivated the launch of a
joint project between the Federal University of Rio de
Janeiro (UFRJ) and a local energy distribution company,
concerning the development of a flywheel-based energy
storage device for custom power equipments. Two major
potential applications are under consideration for further
development: the compensation of voltage sags and a
short-term uninterruptible power supply, to provide ride-
through capability to critical loads under momentary
fault conditions.
The performance degradation of the electrochemical
batteries is directly related to the number of charges and
discharges cycles. Furthermore, they are expensive and
not environmental safe [7]. On the other hand, flywheel
energy storage systems (FESS) coupled to an electrical
machine can be used to store mechanical energy, which
can be used in a dynamic voltage restorer, for example.
FESS are environmental safe and do not degrade the
performance with charges and discharges cycles. To
surpass the electrochemical batteries, FESS need to have
better energy volume density, life-cycle cost and FESS
monitoring require less effort than for batteries [7]. The
FESS has the burst risk in case of bearing failure.
The energy stored in a flywheel is proportional to the
moment of inertia and the square of angular velocity.
Then increasing the flywheel angular velocity may
increase the energy density of FESS [3]. When the
flywheel velocity is increased the idling losses are
increased too, due to the aerodynamic drag and the losses
in the bearings. The aerodynamic drag can be reduced
with a partial vacuum in the flywheel container, and the
bearing losses with magnetic bearings [2-4]. Active
magnetic bearings (AMB) are expensive and demand an
energy consumption that have to be computed as a loss.
Superconducting magnetic bearings (SMB) are one
alternative to AMB, they are entirely passive and do not
suffer from catastrophic failure as the AMB does. The
SMB will fail if its cooling system fails and the
superconductors warm up, but this will be a gradual
process [4]. As the price of superconductors is still high,
the overall system cost may be reduced if the SMB is
used together with a permanent magnetic bearing (PMB)
in an Evershed arrangement. In this case the PMB does
the most of efforts to bear the flywheel and motor and
the SMB gives stability to the whole set.
Other significant aspect of the energy storage device is
concerned to the electromechanical energy conversion
between the flywheel and the electrical system. In order
to use the most of the stored kinetic energy in the
flywheel, the electrical machine has to be electronically
controlled. It is usual to use a permanent magnet
synchronous machine in flywheel projects [2,4], but the
permanent magnet machines always have idling losses
related to the eddy currents induced by the magnetic field
on the stator. This can be avoided using a switched
reluctance machine (SRM), which has a null idle
magnetic field [5]. The SRM can work at very wide
IEEE ISIE 2006, July 9-12, 2006, Montréal, Québec, Canada
1-4244-0497-5/06/$20.00 © 2006 IEEE 2492