International Journal of Engineering & Technology IJET-IJENS Vol:14 No:01 108
147801-6565-IJET-IJENS © February 2014 IJENS
I J E N S
Appraisal of Timber as Structural Members for
Residential Buildings in Nigeria
Anthony Nkem Ede (PhD) and Joshua Omoruyi Okundaye
Department of Civil Engineering, College of Science and Technology, Covenant University, Canaan Land, KM 10, Idiroko Road,
P.M.B. 1023 Ota, Ogun state, Nigeria
Phone +234-8060-164-058 anthony.ede@covenantuniversity.edu.ng
Abstract - Concrete and sand crate blocks are the most common
construction materials adopted for residential buildings in
Nigeria. They are used in the form of reinforced concrete frames
and sand crate block walls. These heavy weight materials are
mostly assembled on site by bricklayers or masons. The high
demand for these construction materials and the intensive labour
required for site placement have led to high cost of these
materials and consequently to general high cost of construction
in Nigeria. These facts contribute to making the access to good
housing by common man very difficult. It therefore becomes very
obvious that alternative means of construction should be
explored and implemented in order for the average and below
average Nigerian citizen to have a decent roof over their heads.
Based on the rapid advances in the construction materials
technology over the recent years, civil engineers have been
enabled to produce new solutions of built structures to serve the
common needs of society. In that line, this research work seeks to
provide an alternative solution in timber as a load bearing
member for affordable residential buildings in Nigeria. A case
study of 5-bedroom duplex is presented. A concrete design with
Orion R16 software and a manual timber design are produced
for the building with the corresponding bill of quantities. The
comparative studies show that the application of timber as a
structural members will help to drive down the cost of residential
buildings in Nigeria and make them affordable to common man.
Index Term- Timber, Concrete, Structural Elements, Affordable
Homes.
1. INTRODUCTION
The technological advancement of every age has a lot to do
with the quality of materials available for that age. As the
world has transited through the primitive age to the Stone
Age, through industrial age into the current
information/knowledge worker age, so have the dominant
construction materials changed through the ages from earth to
wood, to stone to concrete, to steel to FRP composites etc.
Although the traditional materials continue to be in use over
successive ages, the technological advancement made in every
new age depends most on how these materials are combined to
the advantage of the society in terms of safety, economy and
functionality of built structures. In the last 200 years, rapid
advances in construction materials technology have enabled
civil engineers to achieve impressive gains in the safety,
economy, and functionality of structures built to serve the
common needs of society. Through such gains, the health and
standard of living of the members of the society have greatly
improved.
Generally, the provision of affordable housing for low income
workers in developing countries has become a cause for
concern for Governments. This problem is very acute in the
urban areas with the continuous drift of the masses from the
rural areas to the urbanized areas in search of greener pasture.
Nigeria has the largest population and is the second largest
economy in Africa [1]. With an estimated population of about
170 million, population growth rate of about 2.55%, GDP
growth of 6.81% and annual urbanization rate of change of
3.5%, the nation is in dare need of affordable homes for the
teaming population.
As one of the fastest growing economies in the world, it is
saddled with so many on-going projects, both technological
and infrastructural, executed by Governments and by the
private sector, in the form of small scale and large scale
projects, all competing to meet up with the high demand
created by the nation’s large population and the high rate of
rural-urban migration. Not minding all the efforts that have
been put in place and the massive urbanization taking place,
the ultimate goal of making affordable houses available for the
masses remain mirage due to high cost of building materials.
This high cost of building materials have been severally
confirmed by many researchers as the leading cause of sharp
practices that have been responsible for the frequent building
collapse that occurs in Nigeria [2], [3]. It must be known that
over 95% cases of collapsed building structures verified in
Nigeria over the years involved concrete and sand crate block
structures. This must not be unconnected to the limited ductile
behaviour of sand crate blocks which very often are exposed
to absorbing excessive loads. The vast variation of the
properties of concrete is another great problem to contend
with. Every proportion of the components of concrete
including the aggregate size has an enormous effect on the
quality such that the general compressive strength is very
easily compromised [4].
Faced with the escalating cost of conventional building
materials, most often imported into the country with hard
earned foreign exchange, there is urgent need to explore new
idea that seeks to encourage the adoption locally available
building materials which will lead to cheaper rural and urban
structures accessible to the masses. The good news is that the
nation is highly blessed with abundant timber which has not
been maximally utilized to the nation’s advantage. Nigeria is
highly enriched with a surplus supply of timber, with various
species of trees that are suitable for construction. The locally-
grown timber for building construction can be easily obtained
from the available sawmills. This method of construction also