Volume 5 • Number 1 • 2000
HELICOBACTER
© Blackwell Science, Inc. 1083-4389/00/$15.00/52 52–56 52
Four-Day, Twice Daily, Quadruple Therapy with Amoxicillin,
Clarithromycin, Tinidazole and Omeprazole to Cure
Helicobacter pylori Infection: A Pilot Study
Xavier Calvet,* Llùcia Titó,
†
Ricard Comet,* Neus García,
‡
Ralel Campo,
§
and Enric Brullet
§
*Medicine and
‡
Surgery Services and
§
Endoscopy Unit, Corporació Sanitària Parc Taulí, Sabadell;
†
Medicine Service,
ABSTRACT
Hospital de l’Esperit Sant, Sta. Coloma Gramanet, Spain
Background. The best regimen for the treatment of
Helicobacter pylori infection has yet to be defined.
Four-day quadruple therapy with tetracycline, metro-
nidazole, bismuth, and a proton pump inhibitor has
been shown to obtain a very high cure rate. However,
the fact that it must be taken four times daily may in-
terfere with compliance. The objective of the study was
to test the efficacy and tolerability of a new 4-day ther-
apy with 4 drugs taken every 12 hours to cure H. pylori
infection.
Patients and Methods. Fifty-six consecutive patients with
peptic ulcer disease and H. pylori infection were treated
with an oral 4-day course with omeprazole (20 mg/12
hours), clarithromycin (500 mg/12 hours), amoxicillin
(1 g/12 hours) and tinidazole (500 mg/12 hours). Effi-
cacy of the treatment was determined at least 2 months
after therapy either by biopsy (in the case of gastric ul-
cer) or by
13
C-urea breath test. A second breath test was
performed at least 6 months after therapy.
Results. Two patients were lost to follow-up. Forty-nine
of the remaining 54 patients were cured at the first con-
trol [intention-to-treat cure rate: 87.5% (CI 95% 75–
94%); per protocol cure rate: 90.7% (CI 95% 81–
98%)]. Forty-three of these 49 cured patients returned
for a second
13
C urea breath-test at 6–12 months. Two of
them were not cured, giving a long-term cure rate of
85.5% per protocol and 73.2% by intention-to-treat.
Compliance was good, although 25 patients had mild
side effects.
Conclusion. This particular four-day therapy is well tol-
erated, easy to follow, and achieves an acceptably high
cure rate.
T
here is currently no ideal treatment for Heli-
cobacter pylori infection [1–4]. Recent recom-
mendations suggest the use of the combination of
a proton pump inhibitor (PPI) and two antibiotics,
mainly clarithromycin and either metronidazole or
amoxicillin [5]. Initial studies reported eradication
rates with these therapies to be over 90% [6]. In
addition, large, multicenter, comparative studies
[7,8] reporting a 95% eradication rate for 7-day
PPI based therapies have been published. How-
ever, results of PPI-based triple therapies have
been found to be lower in many southern Euro-
pean countries [9–11], in recent US multicenter
trials (82%) [12] and even in recent pooling data
studies [13]. All these analyses suggest that cure
rates with PPI-based triple therapies range be-
tween 80 and 85%, depending on the antibiotic
combination utilized.
A potentially useful alternative to triple therapy
is the combination of four drugs, the so-called
quadruple therapy. Most quadruple therapies con-
sist of a combination of omeprazole, metronida-
zole, tetracycline and a bismuth salt for one or
two weeks [14]. Although recognized as one of the
most effective therapies, with eradication rates of
over 90% even with four-day schedules [15,16]
quadruple therapy is recommended only as a sec-
ond line therapy. The inconvenience of its dos-
age—two, three and four times daily—and the
large number of pills required are the main rea-
sons why it is not generally indicated as first line
therapy [5]. Attempts to simplify the therapy by
using a twice daily schedule have produced disap-
pointing results [17]. Against this background, the
aim of the present study was to analyze the useful-
ness of a new, simplified, quadruple therapy with
Reprint requests to: X. Calvet, M.D., Internal Medicine,
Department Consorci Hospitalari del Parc Taulí, Parc
Taulí s/n, 08208 Sabadell (Barcelona), Spain. E-mail: xcal-
vet@cspt.es