Hydrobiologia 386: 27–36, 1998.
© 1998 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
27
Studies on the salinity and desiccation tolerances of Helice tridens
and Helice japonica (Decapoda: Grapsidae)
Koji Omori
∗
, Bambang Irawan & Yoshihisa Kikutani
Department of Biology, Ehime University, 2-5 Bunkyo-cho, Matsuyama, Ehime 790, Japan
∗
Author for correspondence (E-mail: ohmori@sci.ehime-u.ac.jp)
Received 17 March 1998; in revised form 4 September 1998; accepted 16 September 1998
Key words: desiccation, salinity, Helice tridens, Helice japonica, western Japan
Abstract
In the Shigenobu River Estuary (33
◦
48
′
18" N, 132
◦
41
′
10" E), Matsuyama (Japan), Helice tridens inhabits
the mid-intertidal zone to the limit of the high tide, while H. japonica is found around the mid-intertidal zone.
In addition, H. japonica is distributed further downstream than H. tridens. These differences suggest that H.
japonica has a lower salinity and desiccation tolerance than H. tridens. Laboratory experiments on salinity tolerance
confirmed the higher tolerance of H. tridens compared to H. japonica. Helice tridens survived at least a week under
fresh water conditions, whereas most of the H. japonica died. Helice tridens was shown to be more able to tolerate
desiccation than H. japonica, through behavioral, not physiological, adaptation to dry conditions. The present
results demonstrate a stronger adaptation of H. tridens to semi-terrestrial and/or freshwater environments than H.
japonica.
Introduction
Previous studies of grapsid crabs have demonstrated
differences in ecological distributions between sym-
patric species in an estuary, and some factors influen-
cing these differences have been identified (Hartnoll,
1965; Warner, 1969; Griffin, 1971; Jones & Simons,
1982). The results of these various studies indicate that
the characteristics of the substratum, as well as stress
due to desiccation and salinity have important effects
on the vertical and horizontal distributions of grapsid
crabs in the intertidal zone. Amongst these factors,
salinity is the most important factor controlling dis-
tributions within a defined tolerance range; outside
this range other factors may take over primary con-
trol (Kinne, 1971; Jones & Simons, 1982). Jones &
Simons (1982) reported that the vertical separation of
Macrophthalmus hirtipes and Helice crassa appears to
be the result not of interspecific differences in desic-
cation tolerance but rather of feeding and burrowing
behaviors related to the different substrata they oc-
cupy. In some cases, biological interactions between
species, for example, Helice tridens and Macrophthal-
mus japonicus, may be a more important factor in the
determination of small-scale distribution (Kurihara et
al., 1989a, b).
The closely related mud crabs Helice tridens de
Haan and H. japonica Sakai and Yatsuzuka occur
sympatrically in high densities in estuaries and salt
marshes throughout western Japan (Sakai, 1976; Sakai
& Yatsuzuka, 1979). In the Shigenobu River Estuary
(33
◦
48
′
18" N, 132
◦
41
′
10" E), Matsuyama, they are
horizontally separated, with H. tridens inhabiting the
entire estuary, but Helice japonica being restricted to
the lower estuary (Omori et al., 1997). In the present
study, we examined the salinity and desiccation toler-
ance of Helice tridens and H. japonica in an attempt
to explain these distributions.
Materials and methods
Field measurements
In 1990, six sampling stations were chosen in the
Shigenobu River Estuary (Figure 1) to reconfirm the