CURRENT CONCEPTS
Ethics and Professionalism for Hand Surgeons
Ghazi Rayan, MD, Steve Glickel, MD
B
EYOND THE PRECEPT of “first, do no harm,” our
ethical code dictates that we place the welfare of
those in our charge beyond all other concerns.
Our commitment to professionalism ensures that we
perform our duties in a mindful, respectful manner that
takes into account both the physical and the psychoso-
cial manifestations of disease. Paul Starr, in his classic
book The Social Transformation of American Medi-
cine,
1
defined the medical profession as “an occupation
that regulates itself through systemic, required training
and collegial discipline...and that has a service rather
than profit orientation, enshrined in its code of ethics.”
Put together, the realization of our dedication to ethics
and professionalism leads to a commitment to lifelong
learning and personal improvement, collegiality and
advancement of the field, and a deep respect and admi-
ration for the trust imparted to us by our patients.
Adherence to professionalism is being promoted at
many levels of medicine, including at the medical stu-
dent and resident levels, as part of the competency-
based educational objectives. Both the American Board
of Medical Specialties and the Accreditation Council
for Graduate Medical Education have identified profes-
sionalism as one of the 6 core competencies, alongside
medical knowledge and patient care, and the specialty
boards have listed professionalism as one of 4 main
competencies for Maintenance of Certification. Spe-
cialty societies, including the American Society for
Surgery of the Hand (ASSH), have created formal pol-
icies and standing committees to promote ethical con-
duct among their physicians and to address the concerns
of their members and the public about the newly emerg-
ing ethical challenges of practicing medicine today.
Under the leadership of Dr. Steven Glickel, a formal
code of ethics and professionalism and a standing ethics
and professionalism committee were created by the
ASSH within the past year. The role of the committee
has been evolving, but currently, it serves primarily for
consultation regarding breaches in the code and for
education and promotion of our values to all ASSH
members. Among our efforts, forthcoming articles in
the Journal of Hand Surgery will discuss vital ethical
and professional issues that are pertinent to hand sur-
geons.
We hope to improve the already excellent quality of
care provided by hand surgeons worldwide by remind-
ing us all of the great privilege that we have earned to
care for the sick, and the great responsibility and com-
mitment that are demanded by that privilege. Please
take the time to read the code of ethics and profession-
alism, and feel free to contact us with any suggestions
or concerns.
Code of Ethics and Professionalism
2
The following Code of Ethics and Professionalism has
been adopted by the American Society for Surgery of
the Hand (ASSH) and sets forth aspirational standards
of conduct that define the essentials of honorable be-
havior for its members.
I. Relationship with patients. The Hand Surgery profession
exists for the primary purpose of caring for the patient.
The physician-patient relationship is the central focus of
all ethical concerns. A Hand Surgeon should be dedi-
cated to providing competent medical care with com-
passion, diligence, and respect for the patient. The Hand
Surgeon may determine whether to accept the care of a
patient, but should not decline to accept a patient on the
basis of race, color, religion, sex, age, national origin, or
a disability. Having undertaken a patient’s care and
having not been released from responsibility by the
patient, the Hand Surgeon may discontinue services
only after giving adequate notice so that the patient may
obtain alternative care. The Hand Surgeon shall explain
to the patient in understandable terms, the options for
treatment, the reasons for the recommended course, and
the risks and benefits associated with the recommended
and alternative options.
II. Decency and integrity. The Hand Surgeon should main-
tain a reputation for decency, honesty, tolerance and
truthfulness with patients and colleagues. The Hand
Surgeon should not engage in any behavior that would
From the Division of Hand Surgery, INTEGRIS Baptist Medical Center, Oklahoma City, OK; and C.V. Starr
Hand Surgery Center, St. Luke’s-Roosevelt Hospital, New York, NY.
Received for publication June 11, 2010; accepted June 19, 2010.
No benefits in any form have been received or will be received related directly or indirectly to the
subject of this article.
Corresponding author: Ghazi M. Rayan, MD, Division of Hand Surgery, INTEGRIS Baptist Medical
Center, 3366 NW Expressway, Oklahoma City, OK; e-mail: ouhsgmr@aol.com.
0363-5023/10/35A09-0033$36.00/0
doi:10.1016/j.jhsa.2010.06.022
Current Concepts
1554 © Published by Elsevier, Inc. on behalf of the ASSH.