International Journal of Energy Science (IJES) Volume 4 Issue 3, June 2014 www.ijesci.org
doi: 10.14355/ijes.2014.0403.05
101
Production of 14 MeV Neutrons Using
Pyroelectric Crystals: Reconverting Solar
Energy into Nuclear Fusion Energy
Werner Tornow
Department of Physics, Duke University and Triangle Universities Nuclear Laboratory, Durham, NC, USA
tornow@tunl.duke.edu
Received 19 March 2014; Accepted 27 March 2014; Published 25 April 2014
© 2014 Science and Engineering Publishing Company
Abstract
By changing the temperature of a LiTaO3 pyroelectric
double‐crystal arrangement in a deuterium gas environment,
deuterium ions were produced and accelerated towards a
tritiated target, producing 14 MeV neutrons via the
3
H(d,n)
4
He nuclear fusion reaction.
Keywords
Nuclear Fusion; Fusion Reactions in the Sun; Neutron Production;
Pyroelectric Crystals
Introduction
In continuation of our previous work which has
focused on initiating the
2
H(d,n)
3
He nuclear fusion
reaction with a pyroelectric double‐crystal
arrangement (Tornow et al, 2010), we turned our
attention to the
3
H(d,n)
4
He nuclear fusion reaction
with the goal of producing 14 MeV neutrons. At a first
glance this task seems easier than that involving the
2
H(d,n)
3
He reaction with its relatively small Q‐value of
+3.27 MeV and its very small reaction cross section of
about 16 mb at 100 keV, compared to +17.59 MeV and
almost 5000 mb, respectively, for the
3
H(d,n)
4
He
reaction. However, the safety requirements associated
with the use of tritium, and another tritium‐target
related issue, pose severe constraints on operating our
standard pyroelectric crystal apparatus in a university
environment.
Although the
3
H(d,n)
4
He reaction is not very
important to our Sun’s energy production, it does take
place in the Sun, and it is generally considered as the
most practical candidate to reach or even exceed the
break‐even point in a controlled fashion on Earth, for
example, at the National Ignition Facility (NIF)
1
at
Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, or at the
International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor
(ITER)
2
at Cadarache in France.
A number of conflicting publications exist about the
yield of neutrons produced in another fusion reaction,
the
2
H(d,n)
3
He reaction. The work of the RPI group
(Geuther, Danon, and Saglime, 2006; Geuther and
Danon, 2007; Gillich et al, 2009) provides convincing
evidence that neutrons were produced via this
reaction. However, doubts exist that the earlier work
of the UCLA group (Naranjo, Gimzewski, and
Putterman, 2005; Tang et al, 2007) has ever produced
the reported number of
2
H(d,n)
3
He neutrons. As has
been shown in (Tornow, Shafroth, and Brownridge,
2008), any pulse‐height signals due to 2.5 MeV
neutrons obtained with not sufficiently shielded
neutron detectors are buried under pile‐up events
originating from the intense X‐ray radiation present in
pyroelectric crystal experiments. The suspicion
appears to be confirmed by the UCLA group’s recent
work involving the
3
H(d,n)
4
He reaction (Naranjo,
Putterman, and Venhaus, 2011). In Figure 5 of
(Naranjo, Putterman, and Venhaus, 2011) the pulse‐
height region identified to be associated with
3
H(d,n)
4
He neutrons appears to be again due to pile‐
up X‐ray events, which are misidentified as neutrons
in the pulse‐shape discrimination electronics (Tornow,
Shafroth, and Brownridge, 2008). This conclusion
seems also to be supported by their yield versus
deuteron energy curve (Figure 3 in (Naranjo,
Putterman, and Venhaus, 2011)) which does not follow
1
See https://lasers.llnl.gov
2
See https://www.iter.org/proj