ABSTRACT: Because of the high level of chlorophyll-type com-
pounds found in canola oil, bleaching is an important and criti-
cal step in the canola oil refining process. In this study, a new
method for reducing the chlorophyll-type impurities prior to the
bleaching step was developed. This method is based on precipi-
tating the chlorophyll compounds with mineral acids. Concentra-
tions of chlorophyll-type compounds of up to 30 ppm could be
reduced to amounts of less than 0.01 ppm by mixing the crude
canola oil with a 0.4 wt% mixture of phosphoric and sulfuric
acids (2:0.75, vol/vol) for 5 min at 50°C. Centrifugation and filtra-
tion also were examined as two main methods for separating the
chlorophyll precipitates. The results showed that filtration by a
precoated textural filter with filter-aid clay could separate the pre-
cipitates as well as the centrifugation method.
Paper no. J10858 in JAOCS 82, 679–684 (September 2005).
KEY WORDS: Bleaching, canola oil, chlorophyll, mineral acid.
Canola is one of the most important oilseed crops in the world.
Research indicates that the FA composition of canola oil is es-
pecially favorable in terms of health benefits when used as part
of a nutritionally balanced diet: It has a very low concentration
of saturated fat (only 7%), is relatively high in monounsatu-
rated fat, is among the highest in n-3 FA (10–11%), and con-
tains a moderate level of polyunsaturated fat (32%). Canola oil
is also a rich source of the antioxidant vitamin E. In addition,
canoloa meal is an important source of protein in animal feeds
(1–4).The pigments present in canola and other oilseeds are im-
portant factors, as they can impart an undesirable color to veg-
etable oils, promote oxidation in the presence of light, and in-
hibit the catalysts used for hydrogenation (5–7). The chloro-
phyll content in canola oil is significantly higher than those
found in other vegetable oils and presents one of the biggest
quality impediments for the canola oil industry (8). The re-
moval of high levels of chlorophyll pigments from canola oil
(50–60 ppm) requires large quantities of bleaching clays, re-
sulting in high processing costs and significant losses of oil
through adherence to the clays (9,10). Therefore, a cost-effec-
tive process for treating the oil extracted from canola seeds is
needed to produce purified and degummed oil with low
amounts of these chlorophyll-type compounds (9).
The main reason high levels of chlorophyll are present in
rapeseed is that the seed freezes before it has significantly ma-
tured (9,11). Chlorophyll and chlorophyll-type compounds in
the seed are mostly converted to pheophytin during the seed-
conditioning step that occurs before oil extraction. Pheophytin
is the main chlorophyll species present in crude and degummed
oil (9). Because chlorophyll-type compounds are oil soluble,
when the oil is extracted, it retains a green color, the intensity
being proportional to the concentration of chlorophyll in the
seed (12). Treating oil with mineral acids, such as phosphoric
and sulfuric acids, cleaves the phytol group from the pheo-
phytin molecules to form pheophorbide. The pheophorbide be-
comes protonated under highly acidic conditions and separates
from the oil. Pheophorbide in its natural form is not water sol-
uble, but treatment of its protonated form with a caustic, such
as sodium hydroxide, causes the pheophorbide to be converted
to sodium pheophorbide and become soluble in water (9).
Thus, the pheophorbide can be separated from the oil before
the neutralization step.
This paper examines several treatments of canola oil (con-
taining up to 30 ppm chlorophyll-type compounds), with an
emphasis on the process fundamentals of conventional refining
required to reduce the level of chlorophyll-type impurities prior
to the bleaching step. In this study, most of the operating pa-
rameters were optimized. As used herein, the term “chloro-
phyll-type compounds” refers to chlorophyll compounds mea-
sured as chlorophyll a by an automated PFX-990 Lovibond
Tintometer.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Materials. Rapeseed oils with chlorophyll contents ranging
from 10 to 30 ppm were obtained from Behshahr Ind. Co.
(Tehran, Iran). A bleaching earth, Tonsil Optimum 233, was
purchased from Sue Chemie Co. (Jakarta, Indonesia). A filter-
aid clay (Decalite clay) was obtained from Inorganic Ind. Co.
(Tabriz, Iran). All chemical materials, including p-anisidine,
acids, caustic solutions, reagents, and solvents, were of analyti-
cal grade and were obtained from Merck Co. (Darmstadt, Ger-
many). TBHQ was purchased from Sinochem Tianjin Import
& Export Corporation (Tianjin, China). Textural filters were
obtained from Omid Co. (Tabriz, Iran).
Methods. Crude canola oil (500 g) and a mixture of sulfuric
(98%) and phosphoric (85%) acids in ratios of 4:1 to 2:1
(vol/vol) at concentrations of 0.25 to 0.4 wt% were mixed with a
mechanical stirrer at a speed of 200 rpm, at 50°C, for controlled
times, which is also an important parameter for precipitating the
chlorophyll-type compounds from the oil. The precipitates were
Copyright © 2005 by AOCS Press 679 JAOCS, Vol. 82, no. 9 (2005)
*To whom correspondence should be addressed at Research and Develop-
ment Laboratory of Savola Behshahr Ind. Co., 8th Km Fath Rd., Tehran, Iran.
E-mail: e_sabbaghian@yahoo.com or Bahmaei@SBC.ir
Development of a Method for Chlorophyll Removal
from Canola Oil Using Mineral Acids
Manochehr Bahmaei
a
, Elham sadat Sabbaghian
b,
*, and Ebrahim Farzadkish
b
a
Islamic Azad University, North Tehran Branch, Tehran, Iran and
b
Research and Development Laboratory of Savola Behshahr Ind. Co., Tehran, Iran