Child and Family Social Work 2002, 7, pp 161–175 © 2002 Blackwell Science Ltd
INTRODUCTION
The experience of minority ethnic people in almost
entirely white areas is a relatively under-researched
aspect of ethnicity in the UK. As Charlotte Williams
observes:
Much of the available literature has targeted urban areas with
sizeable ethnic minority populations. Relatively little attention
has been paid to the effects of rurality, isolation and dispersal,
either in respect of the experiences of the minority population
or the attitudes of the dominant majority. (Williams 1999,
p. 270)
There are, of course, significant practical difficulties
in establishing contact with representatives from
minorities in such areas. Obstacles to research cannot,
however, account fully for the paucity of academic
inquiry. Despite the publicity surrounding the murder
of Stephen Lawrence in a white neighbourhood, the
fallacy that racism is not a major problem in largely
white areas is an enduring one. As Pugh (2001)
observes, people make the mistake of thinking racism
arises only in the presence of ethnic diversity, whereas
in fact it is ‘a form of discrimination in Britain that
is predominately constructed and enacted by the
“white” majority’ (p. 42) and it is in rural Britain, of
course, that the white majority is most secure in its
hegemony.
There is a small body of literature within the world
of race equality politics that has focused on ‘rural
racism’. This was initiated by Jay’s (1992) report
about the southwest of England, which was memo-
rably entitled Keep Them in Birmingham. Just as an
account of largely white areas, which concludes
‘there’s no problem here’, is naïvely optimistic, some
of the ‘rural racism’ research seems to mention only
negative experiences. This is true of Jay’s (1992)
report. He interviewed 18 black people, of whom he
quotes only a handful, each quotation illustrating a
bad experience. Titles of publications such as ‘Keep
them in Birmingham’ (Jay 1992) and ‘We shoot them
in Newark!’ (Craig et al. 1999), which take the most
161
Responding to the experiences of minority ethnic children
in virtually all-white communities
Jonathan Scourfield*, Jonathan Evans*, Wahida Shah† and Huw Beynon‡
*Lecturers, Cardiff University School of Social Sciences, †Manager, Cardiff ABCD Project, and ‡Professor of Sociology and
Director, Cardiff University School of Social Sciences, Cardiff, UK
Correspondence:
Dr Jonathan Scourfield,
Cardiff University School of Social
Sciences,
The Glamorgan Building,
King Edward VII Avenue,
Cardiff CF10 3WT,
UK
E-mail: scourfield@cf.ac.uk
Keywords: children, mainly white
communities, racism
Accepted for publication: March 2002
ABSTRACT
This paper aims to contribute to the relatively small body of litera-
ture on the minority ethnic experience in almost entirely white com-
munities, by reporting the findings of qualitative research into the
experiences of minority ethnic children living in the South Wales
valleys. Twenty-eight interviews were conducted with children and
their parents/carers. Interviews with children also included sentence
completion and card-sorting tasks. The paper focuses on the views
expressed about quality of life, sense of community, leisure activities,
experience of racism and dealings with institutions. The children and
adults revealed a complex picture, which challenges both optimistic
accounts of ‘traditional’ communities and also the negativity of pres-
sure group reports on racism in similar areas. There is considerable
variety of experience, mediated by class and gender. Whilst racism is
in many respects an ever-present reality for these children, many of
them find creative ways of responding to their situation. Several also
spoke of their lives in the valleys in generally very positive terms. The
paper concludes by reflecting on the potential implications of the
research for policy and practice.