Application of Wiener-Hammerstein System Identification in
Electrically Stimulated Paralyzed Skeletal Muscle Modeling
Er-Wei Bai, Zhijun Cai, Shauna Dudley-Javoroski, and Richard K. Shields
Abstract— Electrical muscle stimulation has demonstrated
potential for restoring functional movement and for preventing
muscle atrophy after spinal cord injury (SCI). Control systems
used to optimize delivery of electrical stimulation protocols
depend upon algorithms generated using computational models
of paralyzed muscle force output. The existing skeletal muscle
models are either not accurate or too complicated to implement
for real-time control. In this paper, we propose a Wiener-
Hammerstein system, Linear-Saturation-Linear (LSL) model,
to model the skeletal muscle dynamics under electrical stimulus
conditions. Experimental data from the soleus muscles of an
individual with SCI was used to quantify the performance
of the model. We demonstrate that the proposed Wiener-
Hammerstein system is comparable to, in terms of model fitting,
and outperforms, in terms of prediction, the Hill Huxley model,
the most advanced and accurate model previously reported. On
the other hand, the proposed LSL model is much simpler in
terms of the structure and involves a much smaller number
of unknown coefficients. This has substantial advantages in
identification algorithm analysis and implementation including
computational complexity, convergence and also in real time
model implementation for control purposes.
I. INTRODUCTION
After spinal cord injury (SCI) the loss of volitional muscle
activity triggers a range of deleterious adaptations. Muscle
cross-sectional area declines by as much as 45% in the
first six weeks after injury, with further additional atrophy
occurring for at least six months [5], Muscle atrophy impairs
weight distribution over bony prominences, predisposing
individuals with SCI to pressure ulcers, a potentially life-
threatening secondary complication [16]. The diminution of
muscular loading through the skeleton precipitates severe
osteoporosis in paralyzed limbs. The lifetime fracture risk
for individuals with SCI is twice the risk experienced by
the non-SCI population [21]. Rehabilitation interventions to
prevent post-SCI muscle atrophy and its sequelae are an
urgent need. Electrical muscle stimulation after SCI is an
effective method to induce muscle hypertrophy [15], [11],
fiber type and metabolic enzyme adaptations [8], [1], and
improvements in torque output and fatigue resistance [18],
[20]. New evidence suggests that an appropriate longitudinal
dose of muscular load can be an effective anti-osteoporosis
countermeasure [18], [17], [14]. Electrical muscle stimula-
tion also has potential utility for restoration of function in
tasks such as standing, reaching, and ambulating. The myriad
Er-Wei Bai and Zhijun Cai are with Department of Electrical and
Computer Engineering, University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA, 52242, USA.
erwei,zai@engineering.uiowa.edu
Shauna Dudley-Javoroski, and Richard K. Shields are Graduate Program
in Physical Therapy and Rehabilitation Science University of Iowa, Iowa
City, IA 52242, USA
applications for electrical stimulation after SCI have created
a demand for control systems that adjust stimulus param-
eters in real-time to accommodate muscle output changes
(potentiation, fatigue) or inter-individual force production
differences. To facilitate the refinement of control system
algorithms, mathematical models of muscle torque output are
continuously being developed. To most successfully adapt
stimulus parameters to real-time muscle output changes, an
accurate and easy-to-implement model is essential.
Over the last decades, researchers have developed a num-
ber of muscle models aimed at predicting muscle force
output [9], [10], [3]. The Hill Huxley model [10] is the
most advanced and accurate model put forward to date
[4]. Compared to other models, the Hill Huxley model
represents muscle dynamics well. However, its complexity
undermines its usefulness for real time implementation for
control. Identification of a Hill Huxley model is non-trivial
because it is time-varying, high dimensional and nonlinear.
Local minimum versus global minimum is always a difficult
issue for identification, and the user must tune identification
algorithm parameters patiently (including the initial estimate)
in order to have a good result.
Our goal has been to develop a model that is comparable
to or outperforms the Hill Huxley model, but at a reduced
complexity. We propose to use a Wiener-Hammerstein sys-
tem that resembles the Hill Huxley structure but has the
added advantage of greater simplicity. This approach was
previously suggested by Hunt and colleagues [13] but was
deemed inadequate for muscle modeling. By examining the
experimental data sets and the Hammerstein system, we
noted two problems. First, a linear block prior to the non-
linear block was missing and secondly, the static nonlinear-
ity seemed suboptimal. The proposed Wiener-Hammerstein
model overcomes these two deficiencies, enjoys a high
degree of accuracy, and is comparable to or outperforms the
Hill Huxley model. Most importantly, the proposed model
is much simpler not only in the structure but also in the
number of unknown coefficients. The purpose of this report
is to describe a Wiener-Hammerstein system for modeling
paralyzed skeletal muscle dynamics under electrical stim-
ulation. By using actual soleus force data from a subject
with SCI, we demonstrate that this model’s advantages over
previous models are theoretically justified and numerically
verified. Equally important is a demonstration of the useful-
ness of block oriented nonlinear systems together with their
identification algorithms. Identification of block oriented
nonlinear systems including Wiener-Hammerstein systems
has been extensively investigated recently in the control and
Proceedings of the
47th IEEE Conference on Decision and Control
Cancun, Mexico, Dec. 9-11, 2008
WeC05.1
978-1-4244-3124-3/08/$25.00 ©2008 IEEE 3305