Housing in the Broader Context in the United States 695
Housing Policy Debate • Volume 6, Issue 3 695
©
Fannie Mae 1995. All Rights Reserved.
Housing in the Broader Context in the
United States
Anne B. Shlay
Temple University
Abstract
Housing is central to participation in the economic mainstream, yet housing
policy has been fragmented by competing, if not contradictory, goals. This
article proposes an expanded policy that incorporates a stronger link between
housing and economic inequality. Through examples, it argues that housing
policy should be a tool for economic development, strengthening families, and
building community.
Definitions of adequate housing must go beyond minimum physical standards
to include issues that are central to people’s ability to become successful
members of society; housing can be an economic entity, a consumer item, or a
spatial location. Going beyond bricks and mortar—making connections be-
tween housing policy and seemingly separate areas—allows policy to be more
coherent. The article examines the links between housing and three vital
areas: family life, community economic development, and social mobility. This
analysis suggests that the most important housing problems are affordability,
neighborhood underdevelopment, and spatial inequality.
Keywords: Housing; Policy; Community development/revitalization
Introduction
Until the mid-1970s, U.S. housing policy defined decent housing
largely in physical terms (Hartman 1983). Partly because of the
multitude of problems accompanying rapid urbanization and
industrialization, as well as high immigration rates, housing
adequacy was conceived as the minimum tangible set of necessi-
ties required for people to lead healthy, if not productive, lives
(Hartman 1975). These necessities included adequate plumbing,
ventilation, light, and space, as well as the absence of faulty
wiring and malfunctioning heating units. This connection be-
tween housing and health, though not tested empirically, was a
fundamental impetus for the reform movement to regulate
housing (Harloe 1995; Marcuse 1978).
The focus on the link between housing and health fostered a
physically deterministic approach to housing (Glazer 1980).