Hydrobiologia 392: 73–80, 1999.
H.L. Golterman (ed.), Sediment–Water Interaction 9.
© 1999 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
73
Impact of arsenic and antimony contamination on benthic
invertebrates in a minor Corsican river
Christophe Mori
1
, Antoine Orsini
1
& Christophe Migon
2,∗
1
Laboratoire CEVAREN, Universit´ e de Corse, B.P. 52, Corte, 20250, France
2
Laboratoire de Physique et de Chimie Marines, Universit´ e Paris 6, INSU CNRS, La Darse, B.P. 8, 06230
Villefranche-sur-mer, France
Tel: [+33] 0 4 95450030; E-mail: mori@univ-corse.fr (
∗
author for correspondence)
Key words: As, Sb, macroinvertebrates, stream
Abstract
The chemical and biological characteristics of a Corsican river that drains contaminated waters and sediment from
an abandoned realgar mine were studied. The concentrations of pollutants such as As and Sb were found to be
notably high. For example, in the Presa River, downstream the realgar mine, the mean As concentrations in the
water and in the sediment were 3010 μg1
−1
and 9450 μgg
−1
respectively. Species richness and abundance of
benthic invertebrates decreased downstream the As mine. The disappearance of oligochaetes, leeches and a rarity
of mayfly populations have been evidenced. On the contrary, a large increase in species belonging to stoneflies
and gastropods was found. Some species like Baetis cyrneus, Ephemerella ignita, Sericostoma clypeatum and
Ibisia marginata were more sensitive to As and Sb concentrations while others species like Ancylus fluviatilis,
Isoperla insularis, Hydropsyche cyrnotica, Caenis luctuosa and Silonella aurata were less sensitive. The benthic
invertebrates show different reactions in this contaminated environment, which could be explained by their feeding
behaviours and certain morphological characteristics.
Introduction
A decline in biodiversity of benthic communities has
often been related to metal pollution (Clements, 1994;
Gibert et al., 1995; Kiffney & Clements, 1996; Hill
et al., 1997), but As and Sb are not often studied (in
contrast to Zn, Cu, Cd).
Arsenic, and to a lesser extent, antimony, are
important environmental pollutants related to anthro-
pogenic activities. Large quantities of arsenic com-
pounds are released into the environment, particularly
through mining operations and biocidal products; Sb
chemistry is very similar to that of As (Migon et al.,
1995).
As and Sb bioaccumulation has been demonstrated
for aquatic invertebrates by Sanders & Cope (1968),
Schuth et al. (1974) and Irgrolic et al. (1977).
Toxicity and bioaccumulation of arsenic are
strongly dependent on its chemical state, in particu-
lar its chemical speciation (Moore & Ramamoorthy,
1984; Phillips, 1990). Trivalent and pentavalent in-
organic ionogenic forms of As can exist dissolved in
natural waters, as well as organic forms. According
to Spehar et al.(1980) the inorganic form is the most
toxic and its bioaccumulation is more significant.
As
(III)
is considered to be more toxic than As
(V )
(Fergusson & Gavis, 1972; Shannon & Strayer,
1989). As
(III)
probably reacts with SH groups in pro-
teins while As
(V )
, chemically similar to phosphate,
is quickly assimilated by microorganisms (Elinder,
1984) and may inhibit primary production, espe-
cially if the external phosphate concentration is low
(Sanders, 1979).
The toxicity of antimony is less well documented.
The relative toxicity of Sb
(III)
and Sb
(V )
is less known
than that of As, but it seems that the oxidation state
is a factor influencing excretion rate: Sb
(III)
should
be eliminated less quickly than Sb
(V )
(Migon et al.,
1995). Since the chemistry is similar to that of As, fate
and effect may also be comparable.