ELSEVIER
PII: S0269-7491(97)00096-1
Environmental Pollution, Vol. 97, No. 3, pp. 229-238, 1997
© 1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
All rights reserved. Printvd in Crrcat Britain
0269-7491/97 $17.00+0.00
MEASURED AND PREDICTED VOLATILISATION FLUXES OF
PCBS FROM CONTAMINATED SLUDGE-AMENDED SOILS
Ian T. Cousins, Nicola Hartlieb, Claudia Teichmann and Kevin C. Jones*
Environmental Science Division, Institute of Environmental and Biological Sciences, Lancaster University, Lancaster LA1 4 YQ, UK
(Received 7 April 1997; accepted 30 June 1997)
Abstract
A laboratory experiment was carried out to measure
volatilisation fluxes of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs)
from sewage sludge-amended soils. The most commonly
practised methods of applying sludge to agricultural land
in the UK, namely, surface application, ploughing in to
soil and subsurface injection, were simulated inside glass
experimental chambers using an anaerobically digested
sludge and a sandy loam soil. Humidified air was blown
over the surface of the soil/sludge in the chambers for a
period of 32 days, in order to sample a sufficient air
volume to detect the volatilising PCBs. The resulting
PCB volatilisation fluxes from the different sludge appli-
cation methods were quantified and compared. Volatilisa-
tion fluxes of individual congeners were generally highest
for the surface sludge (1-cm depth) application and
slightly lower for the plough layer (5-cm depth) applica-
tion. Fluxes from the subsurface layer of sludge (5-cm
depth) were only quantified for the lightest congeners
near to the end of the experimental run-time. Results from
a multiple regression analysis showed that volatilisation
fluxes of PCBs from the surface application are highly
dependent on both the sludge concentration and the log of
the octanol-air partition coefficient (KoA). A well-known
soil volatilisation model, developed by Jury et al., was
adapted and used to predict fluxes for the different sludge
application methods during the experiment. The model
predicted volatilisation fluxes that were reasonably com-
parable to measured fluxes for some congeners, but for
others predicted fluxes that were more than an order of
magnitude lower than measured fluxes. The model pre-
dicted similar loss kinetics to those observed in the
experiment. Possible reasons for the dissimilarity between
measured and predicted fluxes include inaccuracies in
model input parameters and the fact that the models were
not developed for predicting fluxes from sludge-amended
soils. © 1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
INTRODUCTION
In 1992 1.0x 106 tonnes (dry weight) of sewage sludge
were produced within the United Kingdom (UK)
*To whom correspondence should be addressed. Fax" +44
1524 593985; e-mail: k.c.jones@lancaster.ac.uk.
229
(RCEP, 1996). Spreading onto agricultural land is the
commonest destination for sludge in the UK and in
1992 this was the fate of about 50% of the total sludge
produced (RCEP, 1996). The amount spread on land is
expected to almost double by the year 2005, because the
amount of sludge produced is set to increase to 1.5 x 106
tonnes (dry weight) and because one of the current des-
tinations for sludge in the UK, marine disposal, will be
banned in the European Union in 1998 (RCEP, 1996).
Polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) are just one of a
wide range of organic contaminants that concentrate
onto organic-rich particles during wastewater treatment
and are found in the solid residue known as sewage
sludge. The behaviour, fate and significance of organic
contaminants in sludge have not received the same
amount of attention as metals and no corresponding
guidelines exist as yet in the UK to control the disposal
of sludges contaminated with organics, although there
has been some attempt to set standards for a limited
number of compounds in a few other countries, e.g. for
dioxins in Germany. There is increasing concern about
the presence of certain organics in sludge, in particular
regarding their application to agricultural land and
movement through terrestrial food chains, because of
the reported increased mutagenicity and persistence of
some compounds, including PCBs, in soils amended
with sludge (Duarte-Davidson and Jones, 1996; Wilson
et al., 1996). Contemporary PCB concentrations in UK
sewage sludges are generally less than 1 mg kg -1 (~PCB,
dry weight), but were probably higher in the past
(Alcock et al., 1993).
PCBs have fairly low vapour pressures, but their low
water solubility renders water to air transport an
important mechanism with respect to their environ-
mental distribution, as demonstrated by some of the
Great Lake's research (e.g. Jeremiason et al., 1994). Soil
to air transport has been shown to be an important loss
process for PCBs from soils (Moza et al., 1979; Alcock
et al., 1996) and this mechanism will have a marked
influence on the global distribution of these compounds
(Jones, 1994). The mechanisms involved in the soil to air
transfer of PCBs will involve a combination of direct
soil organic matter to gas-phase transfer and soil pore-
water to air transfer. Despite the significance of soil-air
transfer of PCBs and other persistent semi-volatile
organic compounds (SOCs), there is still a paucity of