Cooling with near-freezing saline improves efficacy of cool-tip
radiofrequency catheter ablation
Eduardo Back Sternick, MD, PhD, FHRS, Luiz Márcio Gerken, MD, Ricardo Baeta Scarpelli, MD,
Frederico Correa Soares, MD
From the Arrhythmia and Electrophysiology Unit, Biocor Instituto, Nova Lima, Brazil.
Introduction
It is estimated that nearly 20% of outflow tract ventricular
arrhythmias have an epicardial origin.
1
Careful assess-
ment of the 12-lead ECG can be of value in recognizing
patients with idiopathic outflow tract arrhythmia.
2
The
most frequent site of focal epicardial perivascular ven-
tricular arrhythmia appears to be the junction of the distal
great cardiac vein and the proximal anterior interventric-
ular vein.
3
These veins are in close anatomic proximity to
major coronary arteries, such as the circumflex and left
anterior descending artery,
4
and there is potential risk of
coronary artery injury.
5
Nonetheless, radiofrequency
catheter ablation in this setting can be performed within
the coronary venous system in most patients using either
regular
6–9
or cool-tip catheters
10
as well as cryoablation
with low risk of complications.
11
We report the case of a patient with idiopathic perivas-
cular ventricular arrhythmia in whom conventional cool-
tip catheter ablation within the great cardiac vein was
ineffective. Successful ablation was accomplished after a
very cold saline solution was used. Therefore, we intro-
duce the concept of cool-tip ablation using very cold
saline solution.
Case report
A 48-year-old woman with palpitations due to frequent
monomorphic ventricular premature beats (VPBs; Figure 1)
and progressive reduction of left ventricular ejection frac-
tion (0.49 at admission) was admitted for catheter ablation.
No reason for left ventricular dysfunction other than the
occurrence of frequent VPBs was noted. Twenty-four– hour
Holter monitoring showed 15.445 VPBs (18% of daily
beats) with three episodes of nonsustained ventricular
tachycardia (maximum of four beats).
Electrophysiologic study and ablation procedures
During electrophysiologic study, three morphologies of VPBs
were identified; one of the morphologies was the most preva-
lent by far (Figure 1). Maximum deflection index was 0.59
(suggestive of epicardial origin).
3
Careful mapping of the right
and left ventricular outflow tracts and of the aortic cusps
yielded no early ventricular activation, which was found at the
distal great cardiac vein (Figures 2 and 3). A first attempt at
ablation was made using a standard 4-mm-tip ablation catheter,
but impedance rise precluded radiofrequency current delivery.
During the same procedure, we also tried a 3.5-mm cool-tip
ablation catheter (ThermoCool, Biosense Webster, Diamond
Bar, CA, USA) coupled with an automatic pump connected to
a radiofrequency generator (Stockert, Cool-Flow pump, Bio-
sense Webster, Division of Johnson & Johnson). However,
even with flow of 60 mL/min, the maximum power achieved
was 16 W, which was not enough to suppress VPBs. We made
many attempts, titrating power output delivery in stepwise
increments of 2 to 3 W, but without success. A second proce-
dure was undertaken using percutaneous pericardial access, but
the proximity of the catheter tip to the proximal part of the left
anterior descending coronary artery precluded delivery of ra-
diofrequency current. The patient then underwent a third pro-
cedure. After the ablation site was carefully selected (Figures 2
and 3), achievement of optimal power delivery inside the great
cardiac vein once again was hampered by impedance rise. At
this point, as a last resort (cryoablation would have been an
option but was not available), we hypothesized that using a
very cold saline infusion possibly could enhance the cooling
effect of the irrigated-tip catheter and allow a higher power
output.
Saline solution temperature measurements
Temperature measurements were made using a temperature
monitoring probe with three sensors (Sensitherm, FIAB-St.
Jude Medical, Florence, Italy) that usually is used for esoph-
ageal temperature monitoring. Temperature measurements
of the 500 mL of 0.9% saline solutions were made using the
temperature probe placed inside a small stainless-steel re-
cipient. Measurements were made 1 minute (T
1
) and 5
minutes (T
5
) after the recipient was filled with the saline
solution (50 mL) in order to assess spontaneous rewarming
of the cold saline solution in the laboratory. Ambient tem-
perature in the laboratory was 21.5° 0.1°C. Temperatures
KEYWORDS Cold saline; Cool-tip catheter; Idiopathic ventricular tachycar-
dia; Monomorphic ventricular premature beat; Radiofrequency catheter
ablation
ABBREVIATION VPB = ventricular premature beat (Heart Rhythm 2010;7:
983–986)
Address reprint requests and correspondence: Dr. Eduardo Sternick,
Rua Correias 281/301, CEP 30315-340, Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil.
E-mail address: eduardosternick@terra.com.br. (Received February 9,
2010; Accepted March 18, 2010.)
1547-5271/$ -see front matter © 2010 Heart Rhythm Society. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.hrthm.2010.03.022