ONLINE PUBLICATIONS: BOOK REVIEW
AJA
115.1 (January 2011)
American Journal of Archaeology Book Review
Copyright © 2011 Archaeological Institute of America
The Black Sea: Past, Present and Future:
Proceedings of the International,
Interdisciplinary Conference, Istanbul,
14–16 October 2004
By Gülden Erkut and Stephen Mitchell (British Institute of Archaeology at
Ankara Monograph 42). Pp. 172, figs. 99, tables 17. British Institute at Ankara,
London 2007. $60. ISBN 978-1-898249-21-4 (cloth).
This book is a result of a conference or-
ganized by the British Academy Black Sea
Initiative of the British Institute at Ankara and
the City Planning Department of the Istanbul
Technical University in 2004. The volume
includes 16 of the more than 50 papers and
posters presented at the conference. The con-
tributions cover the Upper Paleolithic period
to the present day, that is, ca. 32,000 years.
The editors have sensibly divided the volume
into five parts: (1) “The Earliest History”; (2)
“Settlement, Acculturation and Exchange in
the First Millennium B.C.E.”; (3) “Black Sea
Interconnections from Medieval to Modern
Times”; (4) “Social and Economic Change in
the Turkish Black Sea Region”; and (5) “The
Future of the Past in the Black Sea Region.” Of
these, the first two are of particular interest to
archaeologists.
In the first chapter, Yanko-Hombach dis-
cusses the so-called Noah’s Flood hypothesis
of Ryan and Pitman, who suggested that the
Black Sea was a freshwater lake approximately
140 m below the present level until about
8,000–7,000 years b.p. (calibrated), when the
Mediterranean Sea forced its way through
the Bosporus, rapidly filling up this lake and
forcing a large-scale change in settlement
patterns that resulted in the early Neolithic
farmers moving into the interior of Europe
(e.g., W.B.F. Ryan and W.C. Pitman, Noah’s
Flood: The New Scientific Discoveries About the
Event that Changed History [New York 1998]).
Through new research, Yanko-Hombach and
her team reach the conclusion that a gradual
process involving six transgression-regression
stages during the last 10,000 years brought the
Black Sea to its present level. Moreover, the
Bosporus may not have been the only connec-
tion between the Mediterranean and the Black
Sea, the Sapanka Lake and the Sakarya River
being alternatives.
The second paper, by Dolukhanov, is a
report on archaeological surveys from 2003
and 2004 in northern Armenia, which suggest
that this area was quite densely settled with
Achaeulean and Mousterian sites of early
hominids (skeletal remains of Homo erectus had
earlier been found at one site) and Neander-
thals. The Neanderthals were numerous in the
Caucasus, as attested both by skeletal remains
and by Mousterian industries, until ca. 28,000
years b.p. (calibrated). Since there is no clear
indication of authentic Upper Paleolithic sites,
the immigration of modern humans into the
area seems to have begun in the Late Glacial
phase. This last wave of immigration was
characterized by the spread of agricultural
Neolithic and Chalcolithic sites.
The second part opens with an interesting
contribution by Summerer on the archaeology
of the southern coast of the Black Sea in the first
millennium B.C.E., a period and region that,
for various reasons, has been seriously lacking
in archaeological studies, particularly by com-
parison with the northern and western coasts.
The study concentrates on the hinterland of
Amisus, where the archaeological finds offer