PII: S0301-5629(02)00515-X
● Original Contribution
OCULAR DRUG DELIVERY USING 20-kHz ULTRASOUND
VESNA ZDERIC,*
†
SHAHRAM VAEZY,*
†
ROY W. MARTIN*
†
and JOHN I. CLARK
‡
*Department of Bioengineering,
†
Center for Industrial and Medical Ultrasound, Applied Physics Laboratory and
‡
Department of Biological Structure, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA
(Received 3 September 2001; in final form 13 March 2002)
Abstract—The cornea is a major pathway for drug delivery to diseased eye structures. We have investigated the
application of 1-s bursts of 20-kHz ultrasound, at I
SAPA
of 14 W/cm
2
(I
SATA
of 2 W/cm
2
), for enhancement of
corneal permeability to glaucoma drugs of different lipophilicity (atenolol, carteolol, timolol and betaxolol). The
permeability of rabbit cornea increased by 2.6 times for atenolol, 2.8 for carteolol, 1.9 for timolol and 4.4 times
for betaxolol (all p-values < 0.05), after 60 min of ultrasound (US) exposure in vitro. The differences between the
treatment and control experiments were statistically significant after 10 to 30 min of US exposure for all four
drugs. US application appeared to produce epithelial disorganization and structural changes in the corneal
stroma. Further studies are needed to determine the optimal US parameters for a safe and effective treatment.
(E-mail: vesna@u.washington.edu) © 2002 World Federation for Ultrasound in Medicine & Biology.
Key Words: Ultrasound, Drug delivery, Eye, Sonophoresis, Phonophoresis.
INTRODUCTION
Efficient drug delivery into the eye is a significant clin-
ical problem (Sasaki et al. 1999). The internal structures
of the eye are protected by different barriers that make it
difficult to achieve a sufficient drug concentration in
diseased ocular structures. The blood-aqueous barrier, a
selectively permeable barrier between the capillary bed
in the processes of the ciliary body and the aqueous
humor in the anterior chamber of the eye, prevents sys-
temically administered drugs from entering into the
aqueous humor. The blood-retina barrier prevents drugs
from entering into the extravascular space of the retina
and into the vitreous body (Raviola 1977). Topically
applied drugs are rapidly washed from the eye surface
due to rinsing by tears, and absorbed into the systemic
circulation, increasing the chance of systemic adverse
effects (Schoenwald 1990). Most of the drugs that pen-
etrate the sclera (white of the eye) are carried away by
the blood circulation before diffusion to the intraocular
structures takes place (Sasaki et al. 1999).
The cornea is considered a major pathway for pen-
etration of topically applied drugs (Doane et al. 1978). It
is an avascular structure consisting of three primary
layers: epithelium, stroma and endothelium. The epithe-
lium is the dominant barrier for hydrophilic drugs, and
the stroma is the main barrier for lipophilic drugs (Ke et
al. 1999). The barrier properties of the cornea have been
shown to be modified by the application of physical
methods such as iontophoresis, application of electrical
current, and sonophoresis, application of ultrasound (US)
(Cherkasov et al. 1974; Filippenko and Tretiak 1989;
Gvarishvili and Dushin 1999). Sonophoresis at frequen-
cies of 470 to 880 kHz and intensities of 0.2 to 0.3
W/cm
2
applied for 5 min in a continuous mode produced
up to a 10 times increase in the corneal permeability in a
rabbit model, in vivo (Nuritdinov 1981; Tsok et al. 1990).
The mechanism of action was thought to be cavitation-
induced corneal epithelium damage that healed in 6 h
(Nuritdinov 1981).
The objective of our work was to determine if
20-kHz ultrasound, which was shown to be effective in
transdermal drug delivery (Mitragotri et al. 1996), can
increase the corneal permeability for glaucoma drugs of
different lipophilicity. The experiments were performed
in a rabbit model, in vitro, using a vertical diffusion cell.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Rabbit eyes were obtained within 30 min of eutha-
nasia. The rabbits were previously anesthetized, and a
protective ointment (Artificial tear ointment, Phoenix
Pharmaceutical, St. Joseph, MO) was applied in 90% of
Address correspondence to: Vesna Zderic, Center for Industrial
and Medical Ultrasound, Applied Physics Laboratory, 1013 NE 40th
St., Seattle, WA 98105 USA. E-mail: vesna@u.washington.edu
Ultrasound in Med. & Biol., Vol. 28, No. 6, pp. 823– 829, 2002
Copyright © 2002 World Federation for Ultrasound in Medicine & Biology
Printed in the USA. All rights reserved
0301-5629/02/$–see front matter
823