Richa Sethi al. International Journal of Recent Research Aspects ISSN: 2349-7688, Vol. 2, Issue 1,
March 2015, pp. 22-25
© 2014 IJRRA All Rights Reserved page - 22-
Multi Level Marketing: - An Exploitation
of Relationships
Richa Sethi
1
, Dr. Shobha Khinvasara
2
1.2
Suresh GyanVihar University, India
Abstract—The Multi level Marketing, first popularized by Amway, in 1950s in US is gaining pace in India. The annual
growth rate of the Companies in MLM business is expected to be 25%. The India Direct Selling Association (IDSA) has
projected that the MLM industry will be around Rs 8000 crores by 2014. Studies show that consumers have negative
perception regarding Direct Selling organisations and MLM organisations in particular. The aggressive selling
techniques, continuous persuasion by agent, exaggerations of facts in recruiting, boosting of lifestyles of upline
members, pyramid scams and unethical way of exploiting relationships all together form a basis for this negative
perception.
The paper presents the exploitation of relationships viz. family, friends, colleagues and attitude of channel members in
MLM business.
Keywords—MLM(Multi Level marketing), relationships ,upline members.
I. INTRODUCTION
More and more companies today are selling their products
and services directly to customers without intermediaries and
are thus identifying new prospects through a process called
direct marketing. Peterson defines direct selling as “face to
face selling away from a fixed retail location”. (Peterson,
Albaum& Ridgway 1989). Business organisations have long
relied on direct marketing to target customers without
spending a lot of money on retail distribution. However the
Network (Multilevel) Marketers have taken the direct model
one step further, i.e. not only they do the sales, but recruit and
train new distributors i.e. independent sales persons who are
members in the network marketing company. This
‘ingenious’ method was first popularised by Amway in
1950’s.The big trump card in network marketing is the
commission paid not only for direct sales made by the
salesperson , but also from the sales made by the recruits
made by him. That is, if you get friends and relatives to join
up, you get a commission not only from the products your
friends and relatives purchase, but also from the sales they
make to their friends (Bloch, 1996). This ‘special’
opportunity attracts prospective candidates to join network
marketing companies. Studies reiterate the fact that a 100
percent annual turnover rate among sales personnel in certain
network marketing company is not unusual (Peterson
&Wotruba, 1996).
According to the Direct Selling Association in the United
States, 70% of the revenue from the direct selling industry
was generated by multilevel marketing companies (Coughlan
& Grayson, 1998) and most of this came from the better
known companies, such as Amway, Nuskin, Oriflame, that
use multilevel instead of single level compensation plans.
In the case of India, network marketing momentum was
conspicuous in India during mid 90’s followed by the
establishment of the Indian arm of Amway Corporation. The
total turnover of network marketing companies in India was
estimated at Rs.40,104crores in 2014 with an annual growth
rate of 25% (Tribute, 2015). Amway India, Avon,
Tupperware, Oriflame and desi companies like Modicare,
Hindustan Lever Network are the major network marketing
players in the Indian market. Indian Direct Selling
Association (IDSA) facilitates membership to genuine
network marketing companies. The IDSA projection for 2010
for the network marketing industry is Rs.8000 crores.
According to National Council of Applied Economic
Research, the Indian middle class was projected to grow from
1.1 crore households in 2001-02 to 1.7 crore households in
2005-06 and the figure is expected to be 2.8 crore by 2009-
10. The above figures justify the rosy picture of network
marketing in India.
However, studies carried out by Peterson et al (1989),
Raymond and Tanner (1994), and Kustin and Jones (1995),
suggest that consumers often have negative perceptions of
direct selling organizations and network marketing
organization in particular. The aggressive selling techniques,
exaggeration of facts in recruiting and pyramiding scams
(Kustin& Jones, 1995) altogether formed a basis for this
negative perception. Then there are others like Koehn (2001),
who have claimed MLM schemes as unethical, and guilty of
‘exploiting’ relations rooted in love and affection and as such
is socially and psychologically unacceptable to most people
in our society (Bloch, 1996).The researchers in this study
propose to explore whether such a phenomenal growth of
network marketing in India is because of the exploitation of
relationships with friends and relatives.
II. OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
The specific objectives of the study are:
1. To examine the exploitation of relationships in
Multilevel Marketing.
2. To examine the differential effect of two types of
relationships with Friends andRelatives in getting
exploited in Multilevel Marketing.
3. To examine whether the downline members are having
a positive attitude towards theirbusiness