Abstract— The purpose of this study is to design multiple-
input multiple-output ANFIS (MANFIS) models to simulate
and predict the future state of the overtaking maneuver in real
traffic flow for four different time steps ahead. These models
are designed to predict the behavior for 1, 2, 4 and 6 time steps
ahead. Each time step is equal to 0.1 second. In these models,
important factors such as distance, velocity, acceleration and
the movement angle of the overtaking vehicle are considered. In
these models, for all the variables, instantaneous values are used
and none of them is considered constant. The presented models
predict the future value of the acceleration and the movement
angle of the overtaking vehicle. These models are designed
based on the real traffic data and validated at the microscopic
level. The results show very close agreement between field data
and models outputs. The proposed models can be employed ITS
applications and the like.
I. INTRODUCTION
Driver’s error contributes to over 75 percent of road
crashes. A high percent of these crashes are related to
overtaking maneuvers due to its complexity. Intelligent
transport systems (ITS) are under active development
worldwide as a means of reducing loss of life. Since
overtaking maneuver is a complicated maneuver and so
many factors affect it, the automation of this maneuver has
been considered to be one of the toughest challenges in the
development of autonomous vehicles.
Driver behavior can be categorized into three main
behaviors; car following [1, 2], lane changing [3, 4] and
overtaking [5, 6]. Here, the concentration of this study is on
the overtaking behavior as one of the most challenging
behaviors on highways. An overtaking maneuver consists of
three phases: a) diverting from the original lane, b) driving
straight in the adjacent lane, and c) returning to the lane. The
phases of the overtaking maneuver are shown in Fig. 1.
These three phases can be called in short: lane changing,
overtaking and returning. From this point, it is indicated that
the relation between lane changing and overtaking is
intimate, lane changing is an important part of overtaking
process, and it is the base of overtaking, because it is
necessary to change lane before overtaking [7].
Ali Ghaffari is with the Mechanical Engineering Department, K. N.
Toosi University of Technology, Tehran, Iran (e-mail: ghaffari@kntu.ac.ir).
Alireza Khodayari is with the Mechanical Engineering Department, K. N.
Toosi University of Technology, Tehran, Iran, (corresponding author, e-
mail: arkhodayari@ieee.org).
Fatemeh Alimardani is with the Mechatronics Engineering Department,
K. N. Toosi University of Technology, Tehran, Iran (e-mail:
f.alimardani@ee.kntu.ac.ir).
Hossein Sadati is with the Mechanical Engineering Department, K. N.
Toosi University of Technology, Tehran, Iran (e-mail: sadati@kntu.ac.ir).
Fig. 1. Two lane changes during the overtaking maneuver.
In this paper, multiple-input multiple-output ANFIS
(MANFIS) models for modeling and prediction of the
Driver-Vehicle-Unit (DVU) behavior in overtaking scenarios
for different time steps ahead is presented. These models
predict the future value of the acceleration and the movement
angle of the overtaking vehicle. In real driving situations,
driver can only control the steering wheel and the pedals. By
turning the steering wheel, the movement angle of the
vehicle varies, and by pushing one of the pedals, throttle or
brake pedals, the acceleration of the vehicle changes.
The remaining parts of this paper are organized as follows:
Section II describes a brief review of the previously
presented models. Section III presents the new overtaking
models design. Four MANFIS models are designed based on
real traffic datasets to predict the acceleration and the
movement angle of the overtaking vehicle. These models
predict the acceleration and the movement angle of the
overtaking vehicle of 1, 2, 4 and 6 time steps ahead. Each
time step is equal to 0.1 second since the data sampling time
is equal to 0.1 second. In other words, these models can
predict the acceleration and the movement angle of the
overtaking vehicle of 0.1, 0.2, 0.4 and 0.6 seconds ahead. In
Sections IV, the proposed models are evaluated and the
conclusion is given in Section V.
II. RELATED WORKS ON OVERTAKING MANEUVER
MODELING
The study of overtaking models has not been very
extensive. In this section, a brief review on the few
previously presented overtaking models is presented. In
2000, Polus et al. developed a model to estimate passing
sight distance of the overtaking process [8]. In 2003, Naranjo
et al. offered a rule which its inputs were the velocity of the
two involved vehicles and its output was the overtaking
distance [9]. In 2004, Shamir designed a smooth and
ergonomic optimal trajectory for the overtaking maneuver
[10]. In 2005, Hassan developed a mathematical model based
MANFIS-Based Overtaking Maneuver Modeling and Prediction of
a Driver-Vehicle-Unit in Real Traffic Flow
A. Ghaffari, A. Khodayari, Member, IEEE, and F. Alimardani, H. Sadati
2012 IEEE International Conference on Vehicular Electronics and Safety
July 24-27, 2012. Istanbul, Turkey
978-1-4673-0991-2/12/$31.00 ©2012 IEEE 387