Intensive Care Med (1989) 15:$44-$45 IntensiveCare
Medicine
© Springer-Verlag 1989
The ontogeny of the metabolic and endocrine stress response in the
human fetus, neonate and child
M. P. Ward Platt 1 K. J. S. Anand 2 and A. Aynsley-Green 1
1 Department of Child Health, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, The Medical School, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK, and 2Department of
Anaesthesia, Children's Hospital Medical Centre, Boston, Massachusetts, USA
Abstract. Evidence of an endocrine and metabolic
response to stress is evident from the mid trimester of
fetal life. The ontogeny of this response is seen in the
different patterns of response evident in the fetus, neo-
nate, infant and child. These data raise important
issues concerning the management of pain and stress
in early life.
Key words: Stress - Analgesia - Metabolic - En-
docrine - Ontogeny
The metabolic and endocrine effects of injury [1],
burns [2], and surgery [3] have been studied extensive-
ly in adult subjects.
Until recently few data were available on the
metabolic and endocrine response to surgical stress in
neonates and children, and even less was known about
the human fetus. In the absence of such data, anaes-
thetic practice has been empirical. Lippman wrote just
over 10 years ago that in neonatal surgery for patent
ductus arteriosus (PDA), "anaesthetic or analgesic
agents ... in our experience, are unnecessary" [4]; our
own literature review [5] encompassing a total of 1157
neonates undergoing PDA ligation confirmed that
three quarters received no anaesthesia or minimal
anaesthesia during surgery, and a recent survey cited
by Gauntlett [6] indicated that "although 85% of
these (anaesthetists) answering believed that newborn
babies felt pain, only about 5% used narcotic
analgesia in this group and few used local analgesic
blocks regularly'
Because all children have to meet the metabolic
cost of growth and have a relatively larger glucose re-
quirement per unit body weight than adults (because
of their relatively larger brains), they are propor-
tionately more vulnerable to metabolic instability.
This situation is even more pronounced in the new-
born, where with limited reserves of carbohydrate,
protein and fat the baby has to contend with a lower
temperature environment, organ maturation and par-
ticularly rapid growth [7]. The effects of surgery
would be expected to be most deleterious to the most
vulnerable children, and indeed this has been shown to
be the case [8].
Evidence for a classical endocrine stress response
in fetal life comes from studies of amniotic fluid con-
centrations of adrenocortical steroids [9]. These data
imply that the fetus is capable of mounting an autono-
mous adrenocortical response and that maternal
opiate administration may reduce the magnitude of it.
Acute fetal distress at birth is also accompanied by
substantial increases in the circulating concentrations
of gut hormones [i0]: the local action of motilin may
thus provide a physiological explanation for the pas-
sage of meconium that is associated with fetal distress
[11].
Since the fetus can be both a producer and a con-
sumer of glucose and lactate [12], it is possible that
under conditions of acute stress the fetus might pro-
duce a metabolic response such as hyperglycaemia.
However, under conditions of chronic stress such as
placental failure, Soothill et al. [13] have demonstrated
that profound hypoglycaemia and marked hyperlac-
tataemia accompany hypoxia in umbilical venous
blood.
It is now clear that term and preterm neonates can-
not be considered as a homogenous group in the con-
text of their stress responses [14]. Given the same
anaesthetic for major surgery, term and preterm neo-
nates showed substantial differences in their metabolic
responses. Some babies developed a massive stress
response, but in spite of this, glucose and lactate con-
centrations returned to pre-operative values within
24 h post-operatively. Postoperative concentrations of