The Influence of Menstrual Cycle Phase upon
Postexercise Hypotension
JOSEPH I. ESFORMES, FRANCES NORMAN, JOANNE SIGLEY, and KAREN M. BIRCH
Centre fbr Sports and Exercise Sciences, Institute of Membranes and Systems Biology, University of Leeds, Leeds,
UNITED KINGDOM
ABSTRACT
ESFORMES, J. I., F. NORMAN, J. SIGLEY, and K. M. BIRCH. The Influence of Menstrual Cycle Phase upon Postexercise
Hypotension. Med. Sci. Sports Exerc., Vol. 38, No. 3, pp. 484-491, 2006. Purpose: Postexercise hypotension (PEH) has been
observed in males and females; however, the impact of menstrual cycle phase upon PEH has not been evaluated. We examined
the pattem of PEH in the early follicular (EF), late follicular (LF), and midluteal (ML) phases of the menstrual cycle in eight
eumenorrheic women following 30 min of exercise at 80% lactate threshold. Methods: Supine hemodynamic measurements
were assessed at rest and then for 45 min following exercise. Blood pressure was measured with manual sphygmomanometry, calf
vascular resistance (CVR) via venous occlusion plethysmography, and central hemodynamics with echocardiography. Results:
Cardiovascular parameters did not differ between menstrual phases at rest (P > 0.05). The pattern of PEH was unaffected by menstrual
phase, but mean arterial and diastolic (DBP) pressures dropped to significantly lower levels across the recovery period in the EF phase
than in the LF and ML phases (mean DBP EF: 69 + 4; LF 74 ± 3; ML 72 ± 5; P < 0.05). Postexercise cardiac output, stroke volume,
ejection fraction, left ventricular dimensions, and heart rate did not differ across menstrual phases (P > 0.05). These parameters,
except for left ventricular dimensions in systole and heart rate, varied with recovery time, increasing to a peak between 5 and 10 min
postexercise (P < (0.05). CVR displayed a significant interaction between cycle phase and recovery time as resistance increased to
greater values in the ML phase compared with the EF and LF phases following 30 min of postexercise recovery (P < 0.05).
Conclusion: Buffering of PEH appears to be enhanced in the LF and ML phases of the cycle where estrogen concentrations are
known to be elevated. Key Words: HEMODYNAMICS, ECHOCARDIOGRAPHY, VENOUS OCCLUSION PLETHYSMOGRA-
PHY, ESTROGEN, PROGESTERONE
he decreases in blood pressures that instantly follow a
single bout of exercise (postexercise hypotension
(PEH)) are well documented in both hypertensive
and normotensive individuals (3,31). Indeed, resting blood
pressure becomes normalized for hours following acute
exercise in hypertensives (1), and this acute effect is thought
to be one of the mechanisms explaining the longer-term
positive impact of repetitive exercise training upon hyper-
tension. Postexercise hypotension has been seen to occur
following both moderate- and higher-intensity exercise (12),
and following exercise of differing durations (23) and mo-
dalities (24), and its length of persistence has been seen to
vary from I to 12 h (18). The mechanisms explaining PEH
are not clearly understood, but have been postulated to be
related to a decreased postexercise baroreflex set point (34),
a decreased vascular responsiveness to sympathetic vaso-
constrictor outflow (15) via either impaired a-adrenergic
receptor stimulation (30) or a metaboreflex effect of accu-
mulated vasoactive substances (13), an elevated sympathetic
Address for correspondence: Dr. Karen Birch, Centre for Sports and
Exercise Sciences, Institute of Membranes and Systems Biology,
University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK; E-mail: k.m.birch@leeds.ac.uk.
Submitted for publication February 2005.
Accepted for publication October 2005.
0195-9131/06/3803-0484/0
MEDICINE & SCIENCE IN SPORTS & EXERCISE,
Copyright © 2006 by the American College of Sports Medicine
DOI: 10.1249/01 .mss.0000193559.98095.ea
nerve activation (16,22), and/or an adaptive mechanism for
maintenance of plasma volume (18).
Establishing the occurrence of PEH has historically been
undertaken in male subjects, although the influence of
gender upon the magnitude and temporal pattern of PEH
has recently been evaluated. Carter et al. (5) reported a
greater magnitude of nadir in mean arterial pressure in
men, compared with women, during 5 min of recovery
from a 3-min bout of exercise conducted at 60% maximal
heart rate. However, the magnitude and pattern of PEH
during 60 min of recovery, following 60 min of exercise at
60% peak oxygen uptake, was shown to be similar in
endurance-trained women and sedentary men and women
(33). The authors reported that in these subjects, PEH
occurred as a result of peripheral vasodilation, but that in
an additional group of endurance-trained men, PEH was
explained by a reduced postexercise cardiac output com-
pared with resting values. It would thus appear that the
pattern of PEH is similar in males and females, but that the
magnitude and underlying mechanisms may differ depend-
ing upon fitness status and the exercise stressor.
Given the variability in reproductive hormones across the
menstrual cycle in females, gender comparisons of PEH
have examined female subjects in a standardized menstrual
cycle phase. Indeed, the hormone estrogen has been seen to
initiate arteriolar vasodilation, and thus to increase blood
flow in eumenorrheic females (21), whereas progesterone
is known to act antagonistically (32). Estrogenically
mediated variability in peripheral vasodilation throughout
484