LETTERS
nature materials | VOL 3 | JANUARY 2004 | www.nature.com/naturematerials 29
T
he future of lithium metal batteries as a widespread, safe and
reliable form of high-energy-density rechargeable battery
depends on a significant advancement in the electrolyte material
used in these devices. Molecular solvent-based electrolytes have been
superceded by polymer electrolytes in some prototype devices
1
,
primarily in a drive to overcome leakage and flammability problems,
but these often exhibit low ionic conductivity and prohibitively poor
lithium-ion transport
2–4
. To overcome this, it is necessary to encourage
dissociation of the lithium ion from the anionic polymer backbone,
ideally without the introduction of competing, mobile ionic species.
Here we demonstrate the effect of zwitterionic compounds, where the
cationic and anionic charges are immobilized on the same molecule, as
extremely effective lithium ion ‘dissociation enhancers’.The zwitterion
produces electrolyte materials with conductivities up to seven times
larger than the pure polyelectrolyte gels,a phenomenon that appears to
be common to a number of different copolymer and solvent systems.
We have previously demonstrated the efficacy of ionic liquids—
liquids composed entirely of cations and anions—in enhancing the
conductivity of lithium copolymer polyelectrolyte systems
5,6
.
However,the mobility of the ionic liquid ions in an electric field can be
prohibitive in achieving the high lithium ion mass transport rate
required for high-rate operation, for example, in a lithium battery.
Hence, zwitterions such as those shown in Fig. 1, which are structurally
similar to the successful imidazolium-based ionic liquids, but with
covalently bonded cations and anions, were identified as potential
dissociating agents, without the associated problems of ion mobility.
The zwitterion 1-butylimidazolium-3-(n-butanesulphonate)
(Fig. 1) was synthesized by procedures similar to those by
Yoshizawa et al.
7
, who reported the use of structurally analogous
zwitterionic compounds as dissociation-enhancing solvents for
lithium salts such as lithium bis(trifluoromethanesulphonyl)amide.
They also reported the effect of addition of a neutral polymer to these
systems
8
, observing enhanced conductivities (up to 10
–6
S cm
–1
) and a
lithium ion transport number of 0.57. However, the use of lithium
salts in these systems means that the problems of competing ion
migration remains. Use of a lithium polymer, as reported here, in
combination with the zwitterions as a dissociation enhancer, results
in a single-ion conducting system, with only the lithium ions
contributing to the conductivity of the system, and hence allows the
high lithium ion transport number that is required for electrolytes for
lithium ion secondary-battery applications. The zwitterion is a white
powder at room temperature, of melting point 152 °C, with an
inherently low conductivity (<10
–7
S cm
–1
at 70 °C). The solid-state
structure has been investigated by X-ray crystallography
9
.
The applicability of this material as a lithium ion dissociator in
a range of lithium polyelectrolyte systems was first examined using a
random copolymer of 10 wt% lithium 2-acrylamido-2-methyl-1-
propanesulphonic acid (AMPSLi) and 90 wt% N, N′-dimethylacryl
amide (DMAA). The copolymer is a transparent solid material,
P(AMPSLi-c-DMAA), at room temperature. Clear, flexible
polyelectrolyte gels were prepared by mixing this copolymer with
propylene carbonate (PC), with or without zwitterion, and stirring at
60 °C for 24 hours. The zwitterion becomes insoluble in this system at
concentrations of 10 wt% and above, and so was used at a weight ratio
of copolyme/zwitterions/solvent of 1:1:9. Figure 2a shows the
startling effect of addition of 9 wt% zwitterion on this system, with
the conductivity more than tripling (5.6 × 10
–5
S cm
–1
compared
with 1.6 × 10
–5
S cm
–1
at 30 °C).
The applicability of the zwitterion effect to other polyelectrolyte
systems was investigated using a lithium methyl acrylate copolymer
system, P(MALi-c-DMAA), composed of 10 mol% of lithium
methacrylate (MALi) and 90 mol% of N,N′-dimethylacryl amide
(DMAA). In this system polyethyleneglycol (PEG) was used as a
solvent,and again the polyelectrolyte formed was a clear elastomeric gel
at room temperature. As before, addition of 9 wt% zwitterion to this
system results in an increase in conductivity (3.87 × 10
–5
compared with
1.98 × 10
–5
S cm
–1
at 70 °C),shown in Fig. 2b. Thus, the zwitterion effect
is not a unique feature of one system, but is equally applicable to other
copolymers and, importantly, to different solvent systems.
Figure 1 The zwitterion 1-butylimidazolium-3-(n-butanesulphonate).
The zwitterion effect in high-conductivity
polyelectrolyte materials
CHURAT TIYAPIBOONCHAIYA
1
, JENNIFER M. PRINGLE
1
, JIAZENG SUN
2
, NOLENE BYRNE
2
,
PATRICK C. HOWLETT
1
, DOUGLAS R. MACFARLANE*
1
AND MARIA FORSYTH
2
1
School of Chemistry and
2
School of Physics and Materials Engineering, Monash University, Wellington Road, Clayton, Victoria 3800, Australia
*e-mail: Douglas.MacFARLANE@sci.monash.edu.au
Published online: 21 December 2003; doi:10.1038/nmat1044
SO
3
–
N N
+
©2004 Nature Publishing Group