JOURNAL OF PALLIATIVE MEDICINE
Volume 11, Number 7, 2008
© Mary Ann Liebert, Inc.
DOI: 10.1089/jpm.2008.0020
Dying with Advanced Dementia in Long-Term Care
Geriatric Institutions: A Retrospective Study
Paola Di Giulio, R.N., M.Sc.,
1
Franco Toscani, M.D.,
2
Daniele Villani, M.D.,
3
Cinzia Brunelli, Sc.D.,
2
Simona Gentile, M.D.,
3
and Patrizia Spadin
4
Abstract
Objective: The aim of this study is to describe the last month of life of severely demented elders in long-term
care institutions, and the clinical decisions in the management of their end-of-life events.
Design: Retrospective exploratory study.
Setting: Seven Italian long-term care institutions with more than 200 beds.
Participants: One hundred forty-one patients with advanced (FAST stage = 7c) dementia (Alzheimer disease,
vascular, other kinds of dementia, severe cognitive impairment).
Measurement: Diagnosis, Mini-Mental State Examination, cause of death. Data were collected from clinical and
nursing records referring to the last 30 days of life: symptoms and signs, intensity and incidence, treatments
(antibiotics, analgesics, anxiolytics, antidepressants, artificial nutrition/hydration, and use of restraints); the last
48 hours: cardiopulmonary resuscitation attempts and life-sustaining drugs.
Results: Patients were given antibiotics (71.6%), anxiolytics (37.1%), and antidepressants (7.8%). Twenty-nine
patients (20.5%) were tube- or percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy (PEG)-fed. Most patients (66.6%) were
also parenterally hydrated (72 intravenously, 15 by hypodermoclysis). Some form of physical restraint was used
for 58.2% (bed-rails and other immobilizers). Almost half of the patients had pressure sores. In general, atten-
tion to physical suffering was fairly good, but during the last 48 hours a number of interventions could be con-
sidered inappropriate for these patients: tube feeding (20.5%), intravenous hydration (66.6%), antibiotics (71.6%),
and life-sustaining drugs (34.0%).
Conclusions: Some indicators imply a less than optimal quality of care (restraints, pressure sores, psychoactive
drugs, and the lack of documentation of shared decision-making) and suggest that far advanced demented pa-
tients are not fully perceived as “terminal.”
1023
Introduction
D
EMENTIA is a long and highly debilitating illness. Its du-
ration cannot be estimated and is still much debated,
with reports of average survival ranging from 3 to 16 years.
1
During the illness, the patient experiences a progressive loss
of autonomy and capacity, up to complete dependence and
cognitive impairment. This process is gradual and its pro-
gression depends on the type of dementia, age, comorbidity,
treatments, quality of care, and social networks.
2
In ad-
vanced stages patients frequently have to be admitted to
long-term care geriatric institutions and nursing homes,
where they spend the last part of their lives
3
and where they
are expected to receive palliative and end-of-life care. Their
average age is generally more than 80 years. The prevalence
of severe dementia in nursing homes may be as high as
80%.
3,4
Advanced dementia is unquestionably a terminal disease,
but in nursing homes and long-term care institutions this is
seldom acknowledged by doctors and health profession-
als.
4,5
Patients are rarely referred to palliative care services
and hospices, and are often exposed to aggressive treat-
ments.
6
The literature highlights important differences not
only between countries, but even between institutions and
1
Department of Public Health and Microbiology Faculty of Medicine and Surgery, Turin University, Turin, Italy.
2
Lino Maestroni Foundation–Palliative Medicine Research Institute, Cremona, Italy.
3
Department of Geriatrics, Sospiro Foundation, Cremona, Italy.
4
Italian Association of Alzheimer Patients, Milano, Italy.