© 2005 The Royal Microscopical Society
Journal of Microscopy, Vol. 218, Pt 3 June 2005, pp. 240–246
Received 17 May 2004; accepted 15 March 2005
Blackwell Publishing, Ltd.
A simple enzymatic method for examining calcite ossicles of
Echinodermata
C. G. TIAGO*, A. D. BRITES*
,
† & G. Y. KAWAUCHI*
,
†
*Centro de Biologia Marinha, Universidade de São Paulo, São Sebastião, SP, 11600–000, Brazil
†Instituto de Biociências, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, SP, Brazil
Key words. Calcite ossicles, Echinodermata, enzymatic method, scanning
electron microscopy.
Summary
The various shapes, size and fine details of ossicles are of para-
mount importance as systematic characters in the Echinoder-
mata. The ossicles in this group are endodermal and a method
to free them from the dermis is essential for their study. To date,
a small quantity of hypochlorite solution (usually household liquid
bleach) has been used to dissolve a small piece of tissue and,
consequently, free these ossicles. A new method, using a proteolytic
enzyme instead of hypochlorite solution to dissolve holothurian
tissues, is proposed. This method was tested on fragments of
body tissues from three species in three different orders of
holothurians: Holothuria grisea Selenka, 1867 (Aspidochirotida),
Duasmodactyla seguroensis (Deichmann, 1930) (Dendrochirotida)
and Synaptula secreta Ancona Lopez (1957) (Apodida). Obser-
vations of material prepared using the hypochlorite and the
enzyme methods were made using scanning electron micro-
scopy (SEM). The SEM images show the striking differences in
the surface of the ossicles obtained by each method, and reveal
the advantages of the enzyme method.
Received 17 May 2004; accepted 15 March 2005
Introduction
Echinoderm identification is based mainly on the morphology
of the calcite skeleton. This skeleton is composed of numerous
ossicles, united by muscles and other tissues (Ophiuroidea,
Asteroidea, Echinoidea and Crinoidea) or scattered in the der-
mal tissues of the animal (Holothuroidea). The classification of
the echinoderms is based on the type, shape and fine details of
the calcareous skeleton. The identification of these animals
depends on the use of suitable techniques to clean the skele-
ton, or to isolate the ossicles.
The idea of developing a new method to isolate echinoderm
ossicles arose because we had started to work with holothu-
rians with minute ossicles, that usually are damaged with the
traditional method which uses hypochlorite solution (house-
hold bleach) to dissolve the tissues (Deichmann, 1954;
Pawson, 1986; Ditadi, 1987; Hendler et al ., 1995; Cutress, 1996).
However, this hypochlorite solution, when not properly buffered,
can corrode the calcareous ossicles, resulting in modifi-
cation of their shape, dimensions and fine details sometimes
are completely lost (A. S. F. Ditadi, personal communication).
Alterations in the characteristics of the ossicles can even com-
promise the species identification, especially when identifica-
tion is based on slight differences in dimensions and surface
details of ossicles or when the ossicles in young individuals are
very different from those in adults (Cutress, 1996).
Proteolytic enzymes are used in several cleaning processes,
such as in domestic protein-cleaning process of contact lenses,
in clarification of halacarid mites (Newell, 1947) or in the pro-
cedure of clearing and counterstaining cartilages and bones of
fishes (Taylor & Van Dyke, 1985).
The new method, developed to isolate the ossicles of echino-
derm tissues, is based on the step of clearing the muscle tissue
with proteolytic enzyme in a borax buffer in the Taylor & Van
Dyke (1985) procedure.
Materials and method
The following materials were used for the method (see Fig. 1):
pieces of body tissues of echinoderms (fresh or preserved);
distilled water; sodium tetraborate (borax: Na
2
B
4
O
7
·10H
2
O);
proteolytic enzyme; glycerine jelly (Green & Macquitty, 1987),
Permount® or Entellan®.
The enzymatic method for isolating ossicles was tested with
pieces of body tissues of three species of three different orders
of holothurians: Holothuria grisea Selenka, 1867 (Aspido-
chirotida), Duasmodactyla seguroensis (Deichmann, 1930)
(Dendrochirotida) and Synaptula secreta Ancona Lopez (1957)
(Apodida). It is possible to use either fresh or preserved pieces
of body tissues, unless the animal or the tissues were preserved
in non-buffered formalin, which corrodes the ossicles and
precludes the process of identification in echinoderms.
Correspondence: Dr Claudio G. Tiago. Tel.: +55 12 3862 7149; fax: +55 12
3862 6646; e-mail: clgtiago@usp.br