ELSEVIER European Journal of Operational Research 83 (1995) 200-219
EUROPEAN
JOURNAL
OF OPERATIONAL
RESEARCH
Theory and Methodology
The hub location and routing problem
Turgut Aykin
RUTGERS, The State University of New Jersey, Newark, NJ 07102, USA
Received November 1991; revised May 1993
Abstract
In this paper, we consider the hub location and routing problem in which the hub locations and the service types
for the routes between demand points are determined together. Rather than aggregating the demand for the
services, flows from an origin to different destination points are considered separately. For each origin-destination
pair, one-hub-stop, two-hub-stop and, when permitted, direct services are considered. In the system considered, the
hubs interact with each other and the level of interaction between them is determined by the two-hub-stop service
routes. A mathematical formulation of the problem and an algorithm solving the hub location and the routing
subproblems separately in an iterative manner are presented. Computational experience with four versions of the
proposed algorithm differing in the method used for finding starting solutions is reported.
Keywords: Location; Distribution; Heuristics
1. Introduction
Although several studied involving location of new facilities with fixed amounts of interfacility flows
have appeared in the literature (e.g. multifacility location problem, p-median and p-center problems
with mutual communication, Kolen, 1986, and Chhajed and Lowe, 1992), previous research on the
location-allocation problem was focused primarily on the situations involving location of non-interacting
new facilities. It is usually assumed that new facilities would not interact with other new facilities nor
would they interact with the demand points assigned to other new facilities. This assumption of the
location-allocation problem has been relaxed recently in the studies on the hub location problems on the
plane E 2 (O'Kelly, 1986; Aykin, 1988). In a system employing hubs, item flow occurs between demand
points through a set of new facilities (hubs) acting as switching/concentration points. Flows between two
demand points, say i and j, are either sent through one hub, if both i and j are served by the same hub
(that is, from i to hub and from hub to j), or through two hubs, if they are served by different hubs (that
is, from i to hub serving i, from hub serving i to hub serving j and finally from hub serving j to j). Thus,
besides the interactions between the hub facilities and demand points considered in the location-allo-
cation problem, interactions between the hubs themselves exist due to the flows channelled between
them. These inter-hub flows affect both the location and the allocation decisions. The hub location
problem on the plane E 2 with one and two hubs was first studied by O'Kelly (1986) and with three hubs
0377-2217/95/$09.50 © 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
SSD! 0377-2217(93)E0173-U