THE NEW ZEALAND
MEDICAL JOURNAL
Vol 118 No 1215 ISSN 1175 8716
NZMJ 20 May 2005, Vol 118 No 1215 Page 1 of 2
URL: http://www.nzma.org.nz/journal/118-1215/1470/ © NZMA
Horner’s syndrome after central venous catheterisation
John Jarvis, Angus Watson, Greg Robertson
Case report
A 19-year-old female patient presented for surgery with indeterminate colitis
refractory to medical therapy. She had severe diarrhoea despite being on maximal
medical therapy. Colonoscopic examination of the lower bowel demonstrated a
confluent colitis with granular mucosa and a mucopurulent exudate throughout the
colon.
The patient underwent a subtotal colectomy with preservation of the rectum and
formation of end ileostomy. The patient initially had an uncomplicated recovery and
was discharged home. However she became unwell and was readmitted acutely with
peritonitis the following day. An abdominal radiograph suggested there was free gas
in the abdomen, and the clinical impression was either that of a rectal stump staple
line dehiscence or a perforated peptic ulcer.
The patient was taken back to theatre for an exploratory laparotomy, which revealed
an infected fluid collection without evidence of a perforated viscus. An internal
jugular central venous line was placed using the Seldinger technique without the aid
of ultrasound. Central line placement was checked with a chest radiograph and the
position was thought to be satisfactory.
The patient progressed well on the first postoperative day, however the central line
was difficult to flush and back-filled with blood. A blood sample was taken for blood
gas analysis and was found to be arterial. After discussion, the central line was
removed and pressure applied locally to the puncture site for 20 minutes. On the third
postoperative day, the patient complained of a drooping eyelid and slightly blurred
vision on the right side. Her pupils were also unequal. An ophthalmology opinion
confirmed the presence of a right-sided Horner’s syndrome and normal visual acuity.
Three months after surgery, the Horner’s syndrome had largely resolved.
Discussion
Horner’s syndrome is a recognised complication of internal jugular venous
catheterisation.
1
Risk factors for development of the syndrome appear to include:
insertion of large bore haemodialysis
2
or Swan-Ganz
3
catheters, difficult
catheterisation with repeated needling attempts, and accidental carotid artery
puncture. All of these share the likely aetiology of carotid sheath haematoma with
damage to the second-order sympathetic fibres in and around the cervical ganglia.
As in this case, most Horner’s syndromes develop from a neuropraxia caused by a
carotid sheath haematoma—often seen after internal carotid artery stenting.
4
Debate
about the use of ultrasound to increase the rate of successful central venous
catheterisation (CVC) continues,
5
but there is now increasing evidence that the use of
a two-dimensional (2-D) ultrasound guidance increases the likelihood of success, thus
decreasing the incidence of complications and the time spent on the procedure.
6,7