Social Justice Research, Vol. 4, No. 4, 1990
Culture, Values, and Beliefs About Economic
Justice
Kenneth A. Rasinski 1 and Leslie A. Scott 1,2
We examine the relationship between values" and beliefs about economic justice
by conducting a cross-cultural analysis. Social values of Americans and West
Germans are compared and the relationships between values and beliefs about
the fairness of the distribution of business profits are examined. Data are from
the 1984 General Social Survey and its West German counterpart, the 1984
ALLBUS; both surveys contain identical value and economic justice items.
We find that among citizens in both countries beliefs about the fairness of the
distribution of business profits are related to values even when income and
education are held constant, but the relationship is stronger in West Germany.
For Americans, beliefs about the fairness of the distribution of business profits
are related primarily to conservative values (beliefs that greater efforts lead to
greater rewards). In addition, the positive influence of conservative values and
of income level on fairness judgments is greater for Americans with higher
levels of education. For West Germans, beliefs about the fairness of business
profits are related both to conservative and to liberal values (beliefs that class
divisions persist). In general, economic fairness" judgments of West Germans
have a strong ideological basis, but polarization associated with differing ide-
ologies is found. Economic fairness judgments of Americans showed both a
simpler ideological basis and some relationship to self-interest. The influence
of both .{'actors on Americans' fairness judgments seemed to be affected by
socialization due to education. Results are discussed in terms of the prevailing
economic ideologies in both countries.
KEY WORDS: economic justice; fairness judgments; beliefs; values; economic ideologies.
In this article, we examine determinants of beliefs about economic justice
across two cultures, the United States and preunification West Germany.
1National Opinion Research Center, University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois.
2Loyola University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois 60611.
307
0885-7466/90/1200-0307506.00/0 © 1990PlenumPublishing Corporation