Evidence for an Abnormal Cortical Sensory Processing in
Dystonia: Selective Enhancement of Lower Limb P37-N50
Somatosensory Evoked Potential
*Michele Tinazzi, MD, ²Emma Frasson, MD, ²Alberto Polo, MD, *Frediano Tezzon, MD,
*Paolo Bovi, MD, *Luciano Deotto, MD, ‡Francois Mauguiere, PhD, ²Antonio Fiaschi, MD, and
*Giuseppe Ferrari, MD
*Divisione di Neurologia Ospedale Civile Borgo Trento, Verona, Italy; ²Dipartimento di Scienze Neurologiche e della Visione,
Sez. di Neurologia Riabilitativa, Verona, Italy; and ‡Functional Neurology and Epileptology Department, Hopital Neurologique,
Lyon, France
Summary: We evaluated brain stem P30, contralateral frontal
N37, and the vertex-ipsilateral central P37, N50 somatosensory
evoked potentials (SEPs) obtained in response to stimulation of
the tibial nerve in 10 patients with idiopathic dystonia. Results
were compared with those obtained in 10 healthy subjects
matched for age and sex. The amplitude of the brain stem P30
potential and of the contralateral frontal N37 response in dys-
tonic patients was not significantly different from that recorded
in normal subjects. The vertex- ipsilateral central P37-N50
complex, which is thought to originate in the pre-rolandic cor-
tex, was significantly enhanced in patients compared with the
control group. These results suggest the enhancement of the
vertex-ipsilateral central P37-N50 complex might reflect an
abnormal response to somatosensory inputs of a precentral cor-
tex which is excessively activated because of a disorder of the
basal ganglia. Such inefficient sensory processing in motor
areas might contribute to motor impairment in dystonia. Key
Words: Lower limb SEPs—Somatosensory evoked
potentials—Dystonia—Somatosensory cortex.
The precise nature of motor disorders in dystonia is
not fully understood. As far as the motor system is con-
cerned, the primary abnormality is thought to be located
in the basal ganglia which controls movement through
the cortico-striato-thalamocortical circuit.
1–6
However,
the presence of a number of clinical phenomena docu-
menting a modulatory effect of sensory input on motor
patterns suggests that the somatosensory system may
also play an important role in the motor disorders that
characterize dystonia.
7
For example, sensory tricks can
relieve dystonic spasm
4,6,8
; further, vibration can induce
dystonia in patients with hand cramps whereas afferent
block can relieve it.
9
Finally, patients with focal hand
dystonia may have discriminative sensory processing
problems
10
and an abnormal perception of movement.
11
Despite these findings, subclinical involvement of the
sensory system is still a matter of debate. Using the so-
matosensory evoked potential recording (SEP) tech-
nique, Reilly et al.
12
first found an enlargement of the
median nerve-derived P22-N30 response in patients with
writer’s cramp. Similar findings have been recently re-
ported by Kanovsky et al.
13,14
in patients with spasmodic
torticollis, but not by Mazzini et al.
15
who found a re-
duced P22-N30 response, although it must be noted that
patients in these studies had no apparent upper limb
involvement.
There are no reports of cortical SEPs to tibial nerve
stimulation in dystonia. In normal subjects, the scalp
distribution of cortical SEPs consists of a “paradoxical
lateralization,” because the main P37 response which is
followed by the N50 response distributes on the vertex
and on the ipsilateral silent hemisphere with a sort of
phase-reversal N37 response of lower amplitude, usually
over the contralateral pre-rolandic regions. An increasing
number of observations suggests that the generators of
the N37 and P37-N50 are respectively related to the ac-
tivation of the postcentral and precentral cortex.
16–22
To assess possible abnormalities of scalp SEPs from
the lower limb in dystonia, we studied subcortical and
Received July 17, 1998; revision received November 2, 1998. Ac-
cepted January 27, 1999.
Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. Michele Tinazzi,
Divisione di Neurologia ospedale Civile Borgo Trento, Piazzale Stefani
1, 37126 Verona, Italy.
Movement Disorders
Vol. 14, No. 3, 1999, pp. 473–480
© 1999 Movement Disorder Society
473