ABSTRACT: Controlling agricultural nonpoint source pollution
from livestock grazing is a necessary step to improving the water
quality of the nation’s streams. The goal of enhanced stream water
quality will most likely result from the implementation of an inte-
grated system of best management practices (BMPs) linked with
stream hydraulic and geomorphic characteristics. However, a graz-
ing BMP system is often developed with the concept that BMPs will
function independently from interactions among controls, climatic
regions, and the multifaceted functions exhibited by streams. This
paper examines the peer reviewed literature pertaining to grazing
BMPs commonly implemented in the southern humid region of the
United States to ascertain effects of BMPs on stream water quality.
Results indicate that the most extensive BMP research efforts
occurred in the western and midwestern U.S. While numerous stud-
ies documented the negative impacts of grazing on stream health,
few actually examined the success of BMPs for mitigating these
effects. Even fewer studies provided the necessary information to
enable the reader to determine the efficacy of a comprehensive sys-
tems approach integrating multiple BMPs with pre-BMP and post-
BMP geomorphic conditions. Perhaps grazing BMP research should
begin incorporating geomorphic information about the streams
with the goal of achieving sustainable stream water quality.
(KEY TERMS: sustainability; agriculture; environmental impacts;
water quality; nonpoint source pollution; best management prac-
tices.)
Agouridis, Carmen T., Stephen R. Workman, Richard C. Warner, and Gregory D.
Jennings, 2005. Livestock Grazing Management Impacts on Stream Water
Quality: A Review. Journal of the American Water Resources Association
(JAWRA) 41(3):591-606.
INTRODUCTION
Animal agriculture is a significant component of
U.S. agricultural sales, accounting for over 50 percent
of the nearly $200 billion in agricultural products sold
(USDA-NASS, 1997). Beef cow/calf production alone
generated $40.5 billion in sales. Dairy cattle and their
associated products (i.e., milk, cream, and butter)
along with horses accounted for over 11 percent of
sales. In the southern humid region of the U.S., these
14.6 million large grazing animals are a dominant
source of income with a total market value of $2.9 bil-
lion. Considering the large amount of pastureland
and grazed forested lands (15.8 million hectares) in
the southern humid region along with the nearly one
million kilometers of streams, the potential for dam-
age to riparian ecosystems from uncontrolled live-
stock access is quite high (Vesterby and Krupa, 1997;
USEPA, 2000). For purposes of this paper, the south-
ern humid region is defined as Alabama, Florida,
Georgia, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, North Car-
olina, South Carolina, Tennessee, Virginia, and West
Virginia.
Over 36 percent of the assessed rivers and streams
in the southern humid region are classified as
impaired meaning that they do not fully support one
or more designated uses. The U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency (USEPA, 2000) noted that the most
common pollutants to the southern humid region’s
rivers and streams included pathogens, siltation,
habitat alterations, organic enrichment, and nutri-
ents. Sources of these pollutants, while often difficult
to identify, were attributed primarily to agriculture,
hydromodifications including flow regulation and
modification, channelization, dredging, dam construc-
tion, grazing, and habitat modifications including
bank destabilization and removal of riparian vegeta-
tion (other than flow). Underscored by the significant
1
Paper No. 04076 of the Journal of the American Water Resources Association (JAWRA) (Copyright © 2005). Discussions are open until
December 1, 2005.
2
Respectively, Engineer Associate, Associate Professor, and Extension Professor, University of Kentucky, Department of Biosystems and
Agricultural Engineering, 128 C.E. Barnhart Bldg., Lexington, Kentucky 40546; and Professor, University of North Carolina, Biological and
Agricultural Engineering, Box 7912, Raleigh, North Carolina 27695 (E-Mail/Agouridis: cagourid@bae.uky.edu).
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN WATER RESOURCES ASSOCIATION 591 JAWRA
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN WATER RESOURCES ASSOCIATION
JUNE AMERICAN WATER RESOURCES ASSOCIATION 2005
LIVESTOCK GRAZING MANAGEMENT IMPACTS
ON STREAM WATER QUALITY: A REVIEW
1
Carmen T. Agouridis, Stephen R. Workman, Richard C. Warner,
and Gregory D. Jennings
2