International Scholarly Research Network
ISRN Emergency Medicine
Volume 2012, Article ID 340273, 4 pages
doi:10.5402/2012/340273
Research Article
Racial Disparities in Healthcare: Are We Prepared for
the Future? Brief Report on Emergency Medical Services in
a County Health Department in California
Ken Russell Coelho
1
and Virginia T. Nguyen
2
1
Department of Psychology, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA
2
School of Public Health, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA
Correspondence should be addressed to Virginia T. Nguyen, vtbnguyen@mednet.ucla.edu
Received 21 August 2012; Accepted 6 September 2012
Academic Editors: C. C. Chang, W. Kloeck, A. Pazin-Filho, and M. Pocar
Copyright © 2012 K. R. Coelho and V. T. Nguyen. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons
Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is
properly cited.
Demographic trends indicate that ethnic minority populations constitute 25 percent of the current population and will be the
majority of the United States population in 2050. Forty percent of the demographic in California are ethnic minorities making
encounters between healthcare workers and patients from different cultural backgrounds commonplace. Research also indicates
that ethnic minority patients are more likely to utilize emergency medical services as an entry point into the health system due to
lack of medical insurance and access to primary care. Our qualitative study attempts to understand health disparities through focus
groups with 76 patients and their feedback on the use of emergency medical services. Patients revealed challenges in both service
provision and delivery of emergency medical services. Implications include the development of cultural competence training
programs and the selection of diverse groups of county emergency medical first responders in California.
1. Introduction
Ethnic minority groups are moving towards being a majority
of the population in the United States. Recent demographic
trends indicate that ethnic minorities constitute 25 percent
of the current population and in fact will be the majority of
the US population in 2050 [1]. Particularly, 40.5 percent of
California’s population embodies people of nonwhite descent
and 12.4 million of the state’s 31.4 million people speak a
language other than English as their primary language [1]. As
a result, encounters between healthcare workers and patients
from different cultural backgrounds are rapidly becoming
commonplace.
Although US ethnic minority demographics are chang-
ing, disparities in the healthcare system still exist. Firstly,
research reveals that a large majority of American physicians
lack the information to understand how culture influences
the clinical encounter and the skills to effectively bridge
potential differences in communication [2]. Secondly, ethnic
minority Americans represent the unemployed, the under-
educated, the poor, and those from lower socioeconomic
status groups which have been correlated with poor access
to health care services and disproportionate health outcomes
[3–5]. Thirdly, empirical findings document that ethnic
minority patients receive substandard healthcare services
even when income and insurance are the same as their
white counterparts [6]. Furthermore, linguistic and cultural
barriers, stereotyping, biases and uncertainty exhibited by
healthcare providers within the clinical encounter com-
pounded by time pressure adversely effect access to care [7].
In an effort to address disparities, the US healthcare
system has improved efforts to enhance physician cultural
competence; cultural competence modules have been incor-
porated into physician training programs and medical stu-
dent curriculum. However, evidence suggests that ethnic
minority patients are more likely to utilize emergency med-
ical services in the first instance, hence first entry point into
the healthcare system for reasons. Firstly, such patients are
more likely to not have access to health insurance coverage
and secondly are more likely to access emergency medical
services due to ease of accessibility and common knowledge
on the use of 9-1-1 emergency medical services [8–10].