Demonstration of Dual Parallel ) et
Interaction in an In Vitro Model of
Multivalvular Disease by Use of Optical
Visualization and Color Doppler
Flow Mapping
Robin Shandas, MS, Valdir Moises, MD, Benedito Maciel, MD, and David Sahn, MD,
Portland, Oregon
Parallel jets, such as those occurring in the heart in multivalvular diseases like
combined mitral stenosis and aortic insufficiency, have created difficulty when color
Doppler flow mapping or continuous wave Doppler has been used to localize or to
measure the jets because they appear to merge. Dual jet interaction was reproduced in
an in vitro transparent model by driving two parallel adjacent jets, one lower velocity,
higher mass, through a 19 mm
2
orifice, and the other higher peak velocity, smaller
mass through two orifices, 0.2 7 mm
2
and 1.5 mm>, by use of a solution of India ink
and cornstarch to optically visualize the jet interaction and image the interaction by
color Doppler. Consistent deviation of the lower velocity jet towards the higher
velocity jet was observed, and the large jet angled more strongly towards the small jet
for the 1.5 mm
2
small jet orifice than for the 0.27 mm
2
orifice for constant large and
small jet velocities. There was a better linear correlation of the amount of large jet
angulation to the ratio of both jets' Reynolds numbers than to the ratio of both flow
rates. The jets interacted as close as 1.3 em from their point of origin, and the region
after the jets merged was a highly turbulent mixing zone where neither jet could be
separately imaged or visualized. These observations suggest that relative velocity plays
a primary role in determining jet interaction which is a recruitment phenomena but
that other hydrodynamic parameters, such as flow rate and Reynolds numbers,
determine the degree to which the jets deviate. (JAM Soc EcHOCARDIOGR 1993;6:124-
33.)
Turbulent and laminar jet flows produced in the
heart due to stenotic and regurgitant valves can be
visualized noninvasively by color Doppler echocar-
diography.1·8 Although the qualitative clinical use,
semiquantitation, and understanding of color flow
images produced by valvular disease have improved
over the last few years, there still is for the most part
a poor understanding of the color Doppler imaging
of more complex intracardiac phenomena, for ex-
From the Division of Pediatric Cardiology, University of Cali-
fornia San Diego, and the Clinical Care Center for Congenital
Heart Disease, Oregon Health Sciences University, Portland.
Supported in part by a grant from the National Institutes of
Health, #R01 HL42387.
Reprint requests: David J. Sahn, MD, Oregon Health Sciences
University, Division of Pediatric Cardiology, 3181 SW Sam Jack-
son Park Road, UHN60, Portland, OR 97201.
Copyright© 1993 by the American Society ofEchocardiography.
0894-7317/93 $1.00 + .10 27/l/43337
ample, multiple jets such as those produced in mul-
tivalvular disease (combined mitral stenosis and aor-
tic insufficiency). On clinical color flow examples of
mitral stenosis and aortic insufficiency, there has of-
ten been confusion because the jets appear to merge,
13
making it difficult to localize or measure them.
9
-
Further, color Doppler imaging of multiple jets and
their interaction is dependent on the interrogating
plane of examination because both jets do not nec-
essarily have to lie in the same two-dimensional
plane. Our study was designed to explore the hydro-
dynamics and color Doppler imaging of multiple jets
within an enclosed chamber such as those that occur
in multivalvular disease. We reproduced dual jet in-
teraction in a flow model allowing optical visualiza-
tion and color Doppler imaging. The questions that
we wanted to answer were: Do dual parallel jets de-
viate towards or away from each other? What causes
124