International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e-ISSN: 2395 -0056
Volume: 02 Issue: 04 | July-2015 www.irjet.net p-ISSN: 2395-0072
© 2015, IRJET.NET- All Rights Reserved Page 1650
Analysis of Stiffened Plates using FEM – A Parametric Study
Deepak Kumar Singh
1
, S K Duggal
2
, P Pal
3
1
Research Scholar, Civil Engineering Department, MNNIT Allahabad, U.P., India
2
Professor, Civil Engineering Department, MNNIT Allahabad, U.P., India
3
Assistant Professor, Civil Engineering Department, MNNIT Allahabad, U.P., India
---------------------------------------------------------------------***---------------------------------------------------------------------
Abstract - This paper deals with the behavior of
stiffened plates subjected to different loading
conditions. Finite element method is used for modelling
and analysis of the stiffened plates. The maximum
deflection at the center of bare plate is verified with the
reported results. A parametric study is carried out to
estimate the maximum deflection and stress in the
isotropic plates by varying the geometry of stiffener
keeping the constant volume of material.
Key Words: Thin plate, Stiffener, Finite element
method, ANSYS workbench 15.
1. INTRODUCTION
A plate is a flat structural element in which the thickness is
very small compared to the surface dimensions. A plate is
characterised based on its thickness as very thin if width
to thickness ratio is greater than 100, moderately thin if
ratio fall between 20 to 100, thick if fall between 3 to 20
and very thick if less than 3
[1]
.
Of the available plate theories, following two are widely
accepted and used
[2]
,
The Kirchhoff–Love theory of plates (classical
plate theory)
The Mindlin–Reissner theory of plates (first-order
shear plate theory)
Although thick-plate formulation is recommended in
general because it tends to be more accurate. For thin-
plate bending problems in which shear deformation is
truly negligible, the use of thick plate formulation is in
practice because of its easy application. However, the
accuracy of thick-plate formulation is sensitive to mesh
distortion and large aspect ratios, and therefore should
not be used in such cases when shear deformation is
known to be small.
The economical design of plate can be obtained by using
stiffeners instead of increasing the thickness of plate.
Stiffeners are secondary plates or sections used to stiffen
the primary element or member. Stiffened plates are
widely used in different fields of engineering viz. ships,
aircrafts, airframes, chemical industry structures etc. The
stiffened plates are needed to avoid the use of thick plates
that produce high weight for the structures. Stiffened
plates are light weight, high-strength structural
elements
[3]
. The stiffeners enhance the rigidity of base
structures by increasing their cross sectional moment of
inertia
[4]
. The configuration of the stiffeners should be
consistent with the natural modes likely to be excited by
the service loads, so as to arrive at a design with a high
strength-to-weight ratio
[5]
.
The optimum locations of the ribs or stiffeners for a given
set of design constraints were studied by Hasan
[6]
. The
authors found the best design of stiffened plates when
stiffeners were used on either side of square plate. The
stiffened clamped plate subjected to a pressure was
studied by Yousif et al.
[3]
. The investigation carried out to
find out the optimum height which was found to be in
between 40 and 50mm. The relationship between the
deflections of a clamped plate subjected to pressure was
studied by Pedatzur
[7]
. The stiffened plates for various
types of loadings and stiffeners shape were investigated
by Virag
[8]
. Author concluded that the trapezoidal stiffener
is the most economic one. The cost saving can be 69%
when compared with various ribs. Paykani et. al.
[9]
investigated the bending of an isotropic rectangular plate
for various boundary conditions using MATLAB code and
ANSYS. Classical plate theory (CPT) and plane stress
assumption were used.
2. THEORETICAL FORMULATION
The Kirchoff-Love and Reissner-Mindlin FSDT are well
known in literature. The descriptions for these
formulations are circumvented here in for the sake of
conciseness of this paper. Only the Finite element
modeling is presented in the next section, for
completeness of the paper and convenience of the reader.
3. FINITE ELEMENT MODELLING
Finite element modeling consists of four steps: creating
the geometry of the model, generating a mesh for the solid
mesh (i.e. dividing the model into elements), applying
boundary conditions and loadings, and final is solution. A
number of finite element based computer programs
(NASTRAN, PATRAN, MARC, CATIA, ANSYS etc.) may be
used for the analysis of stiffened plates. ANSYS Workbench
15 is used in the present investigation.
A square plate of size 1000×1000×10mm, shown in Fig-
1(a), is consider in the present study and the different
dimensions of stiffeners are used to attach with the plate
by keeping the constant volume of material (10320000
mm
3
) throughout which is presented in Table-2. Although
a many shapes of stiffeners may be used to strengthen the
plates to increase the stiffness of the structures like flat, L-