Engineering Structures 30 (2008) 3276–3284
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Engineering Structures
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/engstruct
A closed-form analysis of perimeter member behavior in a steel building frame
subject to fire
Spencer E. Quiel
∗
, Maria E.M. Garlock
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ, 08544, USA
article info
Article history:
Received 8 August 2007
Received in revised form
12 February 2008
Accepted 1 May 2008
Available online 13 June 2008
Keywords:
Fire
Steel
Performance-based analysis
Perimeter column
Subassembly frame
abstract
This paper outlines a closed-form methodology that can be used to predict the increase in demand
experienced by the perimeter columns that are part of a fire-exposed steel building frame. The two-
dimensional elevation-view subassembly considered for this study includes a two-storey length of
the perimeter column and the floor beam framing into the column in the direction perpendicular to
the building’s exterior. When heated, this beam will expand and induce bending moment and lateral
deflection in the column as well as increased axial force in the beam itself. Our proposed approach has two
primary components: (1) a material model that approximates nonlinearity and considers temperature
effects, and (2) a mechanical model that represents the perimeter column and beam interaction. These
models are used to develop a simplified closed-form solution for beam axial force and perimeter
column bending moment that may be used as part of a performance-based design for fire exposure. The
simplified model solutions are compared to the results of a more complex and detailed multi-story finite
element analysis model. A comparison of these results shows that the simplified model results give good
estimations of structural behavior.
© 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
The current state of practice in the US commonly uses
a prescriptive approach for designing structures to resist fire.
Prescriptive codes state how a building is to be constructed to
resist exposure to unwanted fire. Although this standard has been
used by the building industry for nearly a century, the furnace-
test methodology on which it is based is principally a thermal
test, not a structural one, and it considers individual member
behavior without consideration of how the member interacts
with the surrounding structure. Recent reports by the National
Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) [1] in the US and
the British-based Institution of Structural Engineers (IStructE) [2]
have called for the development of performance-based standards
and code provisions as an alternative to current prescriptive
methods. Performance-based provisions state how the structure is
to perform when subjected to a wide range of fire conditions and
scenarios. Specifically, both of these reports have recommended
the development of a structural design methodology based on
the performance of the structural frame as a whole rather
than the individual components. This research addresses the
recommendations of these reports specifically for the behavior of
steel perimeter columns exposed to fire.
∗
Corresponding author. Tel.: +1 609 258 5427; fax: +1 609 258 1563.
E-mail address: squiel@Princeton.EDU (S.E. Quiel).
The perimeter column in a building is typically laterally braced
by one beam in the plane perpendicular to the exterior wall
or a shaft opening. The fire-induced structural response of this
beam that frames into the perimeter column directly affects the
perimeter column’s behavior and the structural integrity of the
frame as a whole. Previous research by the authors examined the
fire response of a tall moment-resisting steel frame composed of
wide-flange sections [3]. The analysis results indicated that the
thermal expansion of the beams that frame into the perimeter
column induce column lateral deformations (Δ) as well as bending
moments (M
c
) that can reach the plastic moment capacity of
the perimeter columns. Since these beams are partially restrained
from expanding by the column, large axial forces (P
b
) develop in
them. This interaction between the floor beams and the perimeter
column in a frame with one perimeter compartment on fire is
shown in Fig. 1. If these beams, which brace the perimeter column
in one plane, fail, the stability of the column, and the structure as a
whole, may be compromised.
Recent fire-induced structural collapses have shown the
importance of predicting individual member behavior based on
the interaction with the adjoining structure. For example, the
interaction of perimeter columns and floor systems when exposed
to fire has been identified as a contributor to the collapse of
multiple perimeter bays of the Windsor Tower in Madrid [4] and
to the collapse of the World Trade Center (WTC) Twin Towers
[1]. These events have shown us that the perimeter columns
are important to the stability of a structure under fire, and it
0141-0296/$ – see front matter © 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.engstruct.2008.05.006