- Natural avalanche disturbance shapes plant diversity and species composition - 735
Journal of Vegetation Science 18: 735-742, 2007
© IAVS; Opulus Press Uppsala.
Abstract
Background: Disturbances by avalanches have created
unique habitats for animals and plants in subalpine ecosystems
worldwide, but at the same time avalanches can pose a major
threat to humans. Thus, avalanches are suppressed by means
of avalanche barriers to protect settlements and infrastructures
in populated areas of the European Alps. As a consequence,
the disturbance regime in avalanche tracks has fundamentally
changed.
Methods: In the present study we address ecological conse-
quences of avalanche suppression on plant diversity. We ana-
lysed plant diversity and species composition in recent and old
avalanche tracks with and without avalanche suppression and
in undisturbed adjacent forests at high and low elevations.
Results: The number of species was higher in both active and
inactive avalanche tracks as compared to undisturbed subalpine
forest. The species composition indicated a wider range of eco-
logical niches in active than in inactive avalanche tracks. The
vegetation from active tracks showed lower indicator values
for temperature and nitrogen availability. The proportion of
alpine species was lower in formerly active tracks.
Conclusions: The conditions that exist in active avalanche
tracks increase plant diversity in relation to undisturbed forest.
In the few decades following avalanche suppression, species
composition changes in tracks from which avalanches have
been excluded. Continued suppression of avalanche disturbance
may lead to a decline in plant and habitat diversity. Avalanche
disturbance can exert an important influence on the biodiversity
of subalpine forests and provide important habitats. Anthropo-
genic changes in the natural regime of avalanche disturbance
are likely to contribute significantly to future landscape changes
in subalpine forests.
Keywords: Alps; Avalanche; Diversity; Indicator value; Snow;
Switzerland.
Nomenclature: Lauber & Wagner (2000).
Abbreviation: FDR = False Discovery Rate.
Natural avalanche disturbance shapes plant diversity
and species composition in subalpine forest belt
Rixen, Christian
1*
; Haag, Susanne
1,2
; Kulakowski, Dominik
1,3
& Bebi, Peter
1,4
1
WSL Swiss Federal Institute for Forest, Snow and Landscape Research – Unit Ecosystem Boundaries – Alpine Ecosystems,
Flüelastr. 11, 7260 Davos Dorf, Switzerland;
2
E-mail susanne_haag@yahoo.com;
3
Department of Geography, University of Colorado, Boulder, CO, USA; E-mail dominik.kulakowski@colorado.edu;
4
E-mail bebi@slf.ch;
*
Corresponding author; Fax +41 814170110; E-mail rixen@slf.ch;
Introduction
Disturbances are crucial driving forces for processes
and biodiversity in many ecosystems (White 1979; At-
tiwill 1994; Frelich 2002) and they have been found
to often increase diversity. Such disturbances may be
exerted e.g. by animal activity (Fox 1981; Martinsen et
al. 1990). In forest ecosystems, diversity has been found
to increase by high fire frequency (e.g. Glitzenstein et al.
2003), windthrow (e.g. Hiura 1995) or beetle outbreak
(e.g. Stone & Wolfe 1996).
As important as disturbance itself is the suppression
of disturbance by humans to protect settlements and
infrastructure, which can also affect diversity. Such
anthropogenic suppression of disturbances has caused
changes in structure and processes of ecosystems. For
example, suppression of fires has changed the stand
structure of forests, and has resulted in accumulation of
fuels that may have increased the hazard of exceptionally
large fires in certain forest types (Gedalof et al. 2005).
An important but hardly investigated force shaping
ecosystems in mountain forests is disturbance through
avalanches. Avalanches can be frequent and occur several
times during winter (Laternser & Schneebeli 2002). The
resulting disturbance reduces tree growth and density and
creates open habitat in otherwise closed subalpine forest
(Major 1977; Butler 1979). Avalanche tracks contribute
largely to the landscape complexity of the European Alps
and can cover, depending on the topography, more than
one third of the subalpine forest belt (Haag 2006). They
are a preferred habitat for brown bear, caribou and wol-
verine in North America (Mace et al. 1996; Krajick 1998)
and have a characteristic vegetation (Ellenberg 1988;
Erschbamer 1989). Likewise, European grouse diversity
is highest in uneven-aged and diverse forests (Swenson
& Angelstam 1993) and is likely to profit from habitat
created by avalanche disturbance. Although studies
into other disturbances such as windthrow indicate that
dominance reduction of trees contributes significantly to
a high species diversity in the subalpine belt (Wohlgemuth