153 Trop. Agric. (Trinidad) Vol. 90 No. 3 July 2013 0041-3216/2013/030153-07
© 2013 Trop. Agric. (Trinidad)
Correlation of California mastitis test and somatic cell
count on milk of water buffalo cows in the Philippines
Roderick T. Salvador, DVSM, MPH
1,§
, Agnes Alexandria A. Garcia, DVM
1,§
,
Nancy S. Abes, DVM, MS and Claro N. Mingala, DVSM, MVSt, PhD
2,
*
§: Both authors contributed equally to this work.
1
College of Veterinary Science and Medicine, Central Luzon State University, Science City of
Muñoz 3120, Nueva Ecija, Philippines
2
Animal Health Unit, Philippine Carabao Center, Science City of Muñoz 3120, Nueva Ecija,
Philippines
*Corresponding Author: Dr. Claro N. Mingala
Philippine Carabao Center National Headquarters and Gene Pool, Science City of Munoz,
3120 Nueva Ecija, Philippines
Tel. No.: (63) 44-456-0731 to 34; Fax No.: (63) 44-456-0730; Email: cnmingala@hotmail.com
The objective of the study was to determine the correlation of California Mastitis Test (CMT) and somatic cells
count (SCC) on milk of Murrah buffalo cows. It aimed to calculate the prevalence of subclinical mastitis (SCM),
sensitivity and specificity of CMT using SCC as the basis, determine the predictive values of CMT, calculate the
true prevalence of subclinical mastitis based on sensitivity and specificity established, and determine the
variations on the correlation of SCC and CMT against several factors: age of animal, parity number and length
of lactation. Pearson’s correlation analysis and Kappa statistics were used for statistical analysis. Results showed
that Correlation and Kappa statistics had a 23.37% (p <.0001) and 20.20% (p <.0001) respective agreement
between the results of SCC and CMT. SCM prevalence were 30.29% and 23.46% based on CMT and SCC,
respectively. The CMT has 54.43% sensitivity and 77.10% specificity. The positive predictive value of CMT was
42.11% while the negative predictive value was 84.67%. The calculated true prevalence of the test was 23.33%.
Test agreement may change from slight to fair depending on the factors considered such as the age of the
animal, parity number and length of lactation.
Keywords: CMT; SCC; Water Buffalo, Philippines
Mastitis is an infectious disease that causes
major economic losses in the dairy industry
worldwide. Losses are related to the reduction
of milk production, and expenses related to
the additional inputs to reduce the level of
mastitis (Halasa et al. 2007). Around 10% or
more decrease in milk production is related to
clinical mastitis (Dijkhuizen and Renkema
1978). On the other hand, subclinical mastitis
(SCM) can cause two third losses on the total
milk production due to infected quarters
(Radostits et al. 2007). The US dairy industry
is losing approximately $2 billion annually.
Similar impact is observed in Europe and
other countries (Donovan et al. 2005; Denis et
al. 2009). According to Khan and Khan
(2006) as cited by Ali et al. (2011), losses are
also related to earlier culling of animals and
replacements.
While clinical mastitis is easy to detect,
SCM requires reliable laboratory tests.
Undiagnosed SCM might lead to poor herd
udder health as a consequence of pathogen
shedding. The common form of diagnosis is
through the measurement of the somatic cells
present in the milk. Somatic cells are markers
of inflammation. California mastitis test
(CMT) is an indirect method to measure the
somatic cells in the milk sample. The main
advantages with CMT are that it is quick,
cheap, and simple and that it is an “animal
side test” (Sharma et al. 2010). Other indirect
diagnostic tests for SCM for cattle and
buffaloes are the White Side Test (WST),
White Side + Dye (WSTD), Surf Test and the
Surf + Dye Test. Among these indirect tests,
CMT was found to have the highest
sensitivity followed by WST/WSTD and Surf